PDA

View Full Version : UK Declares "Trade War" With Canada Over "Unfair Advantages"


Nephlabobo
03-31-2008, 01:27 AM
U.K. launches trade war over video game industry

Canadian tax credits luring firms from Europe Published: Friday, March 28, 2008


With billions of dollars at stake in the entertainment world's fastest-growing business, the British government is launching a trade battle with Canada over tax credits being used to expand this country's video game industry.
For months, British companies have been decrying the exodus of European game developers to Ontario, Quebec and B.C., where tax incentives are attracting multimillion-dollar investments and thousands of highly skilled foreign workers, whose talents are fuelling the Canadian industry's exponential growth.
"The Canadians have driven a tank over the French Citroen and have now parked on our lawn," Paul Jackson, head of the industry organization representing British games studios, complained to the Financial Times earlier this week. "It is becoming very challenging to keep core development studios here."



Now, the U.K. Ministry of Culture, Media and Sport has formally initiated an investigation of Canada's trade practices through the European Commission, a British government spokesperson told Canwest News Service on Thursday.
"The U.K. government is concerned that state aid offered to computer games companies by a number of federal institutions in Canada may not be compatible with World Trade Organization principles," the ministry said.
In Canada, Manitoba has the most generous tax system, allowing companies to write off as much as 45 per cent of labour costs. Quebec offers a 37.5 per cent labour tax credit. Ontario offers a 30 per cent labour tax credit for small companies, and 20 per cent for companies whose annual revenues are above $20 million. Nova Scotia and Prince Edward Island also have labour tax credits.
In B.C., there is no labour tax credit, but private investors receive a 30 per cent refundable tax credit, to an annual maximum of $60,000, when they invest in new media ventures. Corporations receive the same amount in a non-refundable credit.
If this is indeed an exodus from Europe, it is likely most developers would go to Quebec, where Ubisoft has its largest studio in Montreal.

So, in a country where

A) the industry is attacked from all sides (government *and* church)

B) games are repeatedly banned

C) The film industry wants to take over the ratings of games

D) Politicians make up outright lies about video games (Rape simulator!)

E) The government recently let the UK equivalent of fucking *Dr. Phil* recommend the guidelines for reviewing the game ratings system in the UK

the UK government actually gets *angry* when companies up and leave?

Not only that, they blame someone else for the problem instead of looking long and hard in the mirror at themselves.

This is just idiocy. You can declare a trade war with a country over one *part* of a country (one province - Quebec) giving incentives to business. It's called capitalism.

Between the insane measures that the UK is taking to monitor its citizens, and now hating capitalism, it seems the UK is quickly turning into the U.S.S.R. of old.

Don't want businesses to leave your country? Don't treat them like shit!

lordxixor101
04-04-2008, 10:59 AM
Well, that's just politics. It's far better to blame others than to accept any blame yourself. Why do you think it takes so long for politicians to come out and apologize when they have affairs and lie about it (and are caught red handed).

From reading this, this seems like mostly posturing at this point. We'll see if anything comes out of this. Though, eventual impact on individual gamers will likely be nill.

benjamouth
04-04-2008, 01:12 PM
I'm from the UK and even I think this is bollocks, I'm sick of governments blaming other governments for offering incentives to get in new business. They're all doing it so STFU and stop trying to call people out on something you're doing yourself.

There's a similar thing going on with Europe/USA over Boeing/Airbus, Europe blames the US for offering Boeing too much help and the US does the same to Europe over Airbus. They're both doing the same thing, so why the hell kick up a fuss over it.

Frankly I don't blame governments for looking after their own people, thats what they're supposed to do. If Canada want to offer incentives to make sure its citizens have jobs and a healthy economy then I see no problem in it.

Just to bring up a couple of points to the OP,

C) The film industry won't be rating games, it's just been suggested that the same rating be used for games as are used for films because people are more familiar with them.

E) There is no equivalent of Dr Phil in the UK, and thats they way we like like it, although we certainly have other idiots spouting advice on TV.