Thumbs up or thumbs down

[Xevious]

Thumbs up:
Halo
The Suffering
Burnout 2

Thumbs down:
Bloodrayne
Genma Onishima

What are your Xbox thumbs up or thumbs down reviews?
(remember- keep it brief!)

[Dare]

Thumbs up:
Beyond good and evil
Metal Gear Solid:Substance
Prince of Persia

Thumbs down:
Shenmue II

[slidecage]

all sports games

thumbs way down 50 bucks and they dont even change anything


buy madden 2004 or espn 2004 a lot cheaper then 2005 and its almost the same

[captainfrizo]

Thumbs Up:
Riddick
Full Spectrum Warrior
Freedom Fighters
Halo (of course)

Thumbs Down:
DOA 3
Medal of Honor Frontline

[SneakyPenguin]

Thumbs Up:
ToeJam and Earl III
Panzer DragoonOrta

Thumbs Down:
Just about everything else
Halo

[The Gifuto]

Thumbs Up:
Otogi
Marvel vs Capcom 2
Morrowind GOTY

Thumbs Down:
Aquaman
Tao Fang

[regisphilbi0]

Thumbs Up
ESPN NFL 2k5 (Awesome game!)
Halo (DUH!)
Metal Arms: Glitcth in the System (Sleeper hit!)

Those are the only games I have

[evilpenguin9000]

Thumbs up:
Sex, beer and Halo

Thumbs down:
No sex, no beer and no Halo.

[Scorch]

Thumbs Up:

ESPN NFL 2K5
Metal Arms (Thanks, Guessed!)
Prince of Persia
Beyond Good And Evil
Ninja Gaiden
*looks through XBox collection*
Armed and Dangerous
Deus Ex: Invisible War
Full Spectrum Warrior
Hitman Contracts
Rainbow Six 3/Black Arrow
Spider-Man 2
Breakdown
Crimson Skies

Thumbs Middle (SWERVE~!~!~!):

Halo
Riddick (Just because it's so goddern short.)
Counter-Strike (Great on Live, lack of single player)
Kakuto Chojin (Slow motion when dying rules)

Thumbs down:

Aliens vs. Predator: Extinction (Only because I can't understand it! lol)

[KeyserSoze81]

Thumbs up:
Ninja Gaiden
Psi-Ops
Halo (still playing)
Knights of the Old Republic (still playing)
GTAIII
Rainbow Six 3
Crimson Skies (amazingly fun)

The ehh, theyre okay collection:
Burnout 2
Prince of Persia
kill.switch
Dead to Rights (still playing)
Splinter Cell - Pandora Tomorrow
Riddick
Full Spectrum Warrior

Thumbs way down (as in, couldnt finish bad):
Tenchu (just bad AI and lackluster level design)
Thief (loved first two games, terrible AI ruined it for me)
Blinx (absolutely terrible - good idea turned into frustrating mess)

[CaseyRyback]

Thumbs up:
Halo
The Suffering
Burnout 2

Thumbs down:
Bloodrayne
Genma Onishima

What are your Xbox thumbs up or thumbs down reviews?
(remember- keep it brief!)

I hated Onimusha when I had it for the Xbox. I loved it for the PS2 though.

I would def. give it another try if I were you as it is flat out amazing

[BlueStorm781]

For the games I've played through so far (I actually have more than this, I just haven't played them enough to give a "final" decision):

Thumbs Up:
Project Gotham Racing 2
Rallisport Challenge 2
Project Gotham Racing
Rallisport Challenge
Need For Speed Underground
Metal Gear Solid 2 Substance
Panzer Dragoon Orta
007: Everything Or Nothing
ToCA Race Driver 2
Jet Set Radio Future
Mortal Kombat: Deadly Alliance
GTA Double Pack
Halo
Sega GT 2002 (marginal)
Crazy Taxi 3 (marginal)
Midnight Club 2 (marginal)

Thumbs Down:
Tetris Worlds
Star Wars: Clone Wars
Midtown Madness 3 (marginal)
Amped (marginal)

I've got about 10 more to play through before I make my choice, but this what I think so far.

[Xevious]

I hated Onimusha when I had it for the Xbox. I loved it for the PS2 though.

I would def. give it another try if I were you as it is flat out amazing

Its my understanding that the Xbox version is different than the PS2. The Xbox version has its gameplay tweaked and it is a lot harder too.

In any case, I flat out hated this game. I rather go to the dentist.

[XboxMaster]

Thumbs Up:

Cool thread

Thumbs Down:

I don't have the energy to think of good and bad games

[magilacudy]

Thumbs up:
Sex, beer and Halo

Thumbs down:
No sex, no beer and no Halo.

Thumbs way up!

[el bobo]

Thumbs Up
Deathrow
Metal Slug 3
Halo
Thumbs Down
Red Faction 2
THUG (Tony Hawk Games are getting annoying)

[hollowfreak]

Thumbs Up:
Baldur's Gate: Dark Alliance - multiplayer dungeon slaying ... besides I can run around in my boxers!!
BloodRayne - mmmm she sucks so well ... GET HER OFF, GET HER OFF!!
Enclave - Great graphics, great gameplay, great sound ... great game.
Legacy of Kain: Defiance - "Vae Victus!"
Max Payne - guns, guns and MORE GUNS!
Oddworld Munch's Oddysee - Munch in his wheelchair ... squeaky squeaky
Turok: Evolution - I AM TUROK!!

Thumbs Down:
Riddick - sometimes it really shines but MOST of the time it looks like a psone game.
Malice - could have been great but lacks just about everything
Shrek 2 - YAWN
Van Helsing - is it me or does he just look like an idiot when he runs
Deus Ex: Invisible War - woohoo a slide show

[WildWop]

Thumbs Up:

Shenmue 2
Ninja Gaiden
Gladius
NFL 2K5
Rainbow Six 3

Thumbs parallel to the ground:

Metal Arms
Timesplitters 2
Return to Castle Wolfenstien (enemies don't react to being shot? count me out!)

Thumbs Down:

Crimson Skies (meh)
NCAA 2005 (that framerate has GOT to be some kind of joke)

[evilmax17]

Thumbs down:
Shenmue 2 (too hard to navigate around)
Robotech Battlecry (too mediocre all around for me to finish)

[KurtCobain]

Thumbs down:

True Crime
MTV's Celibrity Deathmatch

[crazytalkx]

Thumbs Up:
Halo
Star Wars KOTOR
Panzer Dragoon Orta

Thumbs Meh:
XII
Sega GT

[Xevious]

Here is an update:

THumbs Up:
Crimson Skies
Psi-Ops

Thumbs Down:
Mojo!
True Crime: Streets of LA (I would of like this game if I never played GTA; Also I hate the cheesy dialog lines)

[Listen To Dylan]

Thumbs Up:
Halo
Metal Gear
Super Smash Bros. (For N64)
KI for SNES (Best Game Ever!)
The Splinter Cell Collection

Thumbs Down:
Gex 3
The Thing
Indiana Jones and the Temple of Doom (The Movie)

[onetrackmind]

Thumbs Up:
Freedom Fighters
Armed & Dangerous
Halo 1 & 2
Gladius
Max Payne 2

[zionoverfire]

Thumbs up:
Growlanser Generations


Thumbs down:
Halo 2

[CaseyRyback]

Its my understanding that the Xbox version is different than the PS2. The Xbox version has its gameplay tweaked and it is a lot harder too.

In any case, I flat out hated this game. I rather go to the dentist.

the tweaks are for the worse. The PS2 version has an element of speed, and the game is never too hard in regards to puzzles. If you have a PS2, you should really try that version, as I felt the same way about the Xbox version as you did.


as far as thumbs up:

Panzer Dragoon Orta
Shenmue II
KOTOR
CAPCOM vs. SNK 2

I have no thumbs down at the moment

[help1]

UP:
SC:CT
Halo 2

Down:
The rest.

[JebusMcLucifer]

UP:
Ninja Gaiden
DOA 3
Splinter Cell (original)
KOTOR
Doom 3

Down:
Sega GT
True Crime