What is the BEST Tasting Peanut Butter I want to know. Answer here!

[Snake2715]

Ok,

I prefer JIF currently. Someone please let me know what other (if any) PB's are actually good tasting. I like both crunchy and smooth but some of these other brands just don’t taste that great.

Respond now so I may be enlightened with peanut butter goodness.

[Admiral Ackbar]

This needs to be a poll.

What do you think lil' John?

http://www.comedycentral.com/tv_shows/chappellesshow/imicons/liljohn.gif

[johnnyoski]

Do we really need 2 topics on peanut butter?

[mcwilliams132]

I'm partial to JIF as well...

Skippy's okay for a change...but I like JIF's peanut taste.

[ryosnk]

Theirs a place in Chicago (forgot the name of it) that sells peanut butter with hazlenuts and almond butter, both of them a very good :wink: .

[Arakias]

Why are there 2 threads on peanut butter? did i miss something new in the world of PB?

[Cornfedwb]

I can vouch for Carb Sense low carb peanut butter being basically library paste and Smuckers All Natural Peanut Butter being absolutely terrible.

As far as good.. I was always partial to Peter Pan.

[cyberlian]

Peter Pan Extra Crunchy

[Admiral Ackbar]

I do't think anyone has mentioned Fluffer Nutter in either thread. Not that I've ever had it.

And no, that is not related to porn.

[Cornfedwb]

I do't think anyone has mentioned Fluffer Nutter in either thread. Not that I've ever had it.

And no, that is not related to porn.

Fluffer Nutter isn't a product (as far as I know) its the name of a sandwich made with Peanut Butter and Marshmallow Fluff.

[Graystone]

JIF

[bignick]

any kind of natural peanut butter is good.

[WeaponX2099]

Peter Pan extra crunchy. mmm its so good!!!!

[ryanbph]

Peter Pan without a doubt

[magilacudy]

I like Skippy Extra Crunchy Honey Nut myself.

[Snake2715]

This needs to be a poll.

What do you think lil' John?

http://www.comedycentral.com/tv_shows/chappellesshow/imicons/liljohn.gif

We can do a poll... I just dont know what the top and best tasting brands are. So I cannot make a quality poll without this knowledge first.

Plus I want to know.

[Cornfedwb]

This needs to be a poll.

What do you think lil' John?

http://www.comedycentral.com/tv_shows/chappellesshow/imicons/liljohn.gif

We can do a poll... I just dont know what the top and best tasting brands are. So I cannot make a quality poll without this knowledge first.

Plus I want to know.

Jif
Skippy
Peter Pan
Other

I can't think of any PB off of the top of my head, other than those first 3 that would get too many votes.

[johnnyoski]

^^^^^
Reese's

[spidey]

Add me to the list of JIF Creamy.

[Cornfedwb]

^^^^^
Reese's

You really think Reese's would get more than a few piddling votes? Its not widely thought of when you think of PB, and its not particularly good.

[johnnyoski]

^^^^^
Reese's

You really think Reese's would get more than a few piddling votes? Its not widely thought of when you think of PB, and its not particularly good.

I agree that it sucks out of the jar, but it sure is good in their peanut butter cups.

[WeaponX2099]

Now that I think about Any extra crunchy to me is good.

and reese is not a good Peanut butter or cereal.

[bignick]

^^^^^
Reese's

You really think Reese's would get more than a few piddling votes? Its not widely thought of when you think of PB, and its not particularly good.

It would be better if it actually tasted like the peanut butter in the peanut butter cups.

[iamarhinoceros]

skippy smooth is the way to go

[tornadomann]

definately Jif Chunky

[Tromack]

We always had Peter Pan in my house. I don't know if in a blind tast test I would pick it, but if I'm at the store and I need peanut butter, it is what I buy.

[Nirvanaguy777]

i like skippy

[Snake2715]

This needs to be a poll.

What do you think lil' John?

http://www.comedycentral.com/tv_shows/chappellesshow/imicons/liljohn.gif

We can do a poll... I just dont know what the top and best tasting brands are. So I cannot make a quality poll without this knowledge first.

Plus I want to know.

Jif
Skippy
Peter Pan
Other

I can't think of any PB off of the top of my head, other than those first 3 that would get too many votes.



Are there any other "non commercial" type brands that are outstanding and any peanut butter lover should try?

Whats the best all natural peanut butter?

[Spiritseed]

Peter pan honey roasted on toasted bread with strawberry jam is the best.

[iamarhinoceros]

throw some fluff in with the skippy and you got a helluva sandwich

[Drocket]

JIF is by far the best.

On a side note, anyone else here 'fix' their peanut butter by adding things to it? I absolutely love JIF peanut butter with a bit of added sugar and quite a bit of cinnamon. I usually have 2 jars of peanut butter at any time, one of them regular, the other my cinnamon-flavored variety (I mix it right into the jar.)

[highwaypatrolman]

have you ever tried adam's? it tastes like real peanuts!

[daria19]

Ok,

I prefer JIF currently. Someone please let me know what other (if any) PB's are actually good tasting. I like both crunchy and smooth but some of these other brands just don’t taste that great.

Respond now so I may be enlightened with peanut butter goodness.

I usually buy JIF creamy, although they have some interesting alternatives at Trader Joe's, if you have one nearby. I have seen cashew butter, sunflower seed butter, almond butter, etc. They are similar to the "natural" peanut butters, where you have to stir them before consumption because the oil has separated at the top of the jar. I have tried the almond and sunflower seed butters, and definately prefer the almond more than the sunflower.

[FriskyTanuki]

I like the generic Wal-Mart PB.

[flowery]

They make JIF just a few streets down from my house and you can smell it everyday, it always makes me make get PB everyday. Its Good Stuff i like the regular and Honey Roasted.

[kelso]

Skippy is by far the best.

[Zmonkay]

jif or peter pan

[Zenithian Legend]

Us horses like JIF