World Series Baseball (Sega) vs. MVP Baseball 2005...which to get?

[nneace]

First I am looking for reviews, but does anyone have any suggestions?

[doubledown]

Check the XBOX thread...there is some discussion about the two baseball games there.

It's been mixed.....some say the graphics took a step BACKWARDS for MVP, and others have raved about MLB 2K5.

[stag8603]

i like mvp because it is just so deep. it is fun to control everything for me. i heard mvp may be 29.99 and ESPN is 19.99, so the price might not be to much of a factor. but i havent played espn, so i cant say that mvp is better, i just have lastyears mvp and loved it.

[Mafia]

Having played both with a friend of mine, I'd give the edge to MVP. We found it easier to get hits in MVP, but after a while 2K5's pitching to use took just a little too long and controls just weren't up to snuff compared to MVP.

Or, you could just do what Monsta Mack and I did and just buy both, since you can get both for $50 total.

[mtxbass1]

I was going to buy both, but after playing 2K5 I settled for MVP instead.

[regisphilbi0]

I picked up MLB 2k5. BUt after hearing everyone rave about MVP, I kinda wish I had gotten that instead.

[tcrash247]

I bought MVP and I'm really liking it so far. I haven't played MLB 2K5, so I can't speak for that, but MVP is really fun.

[FrankySox]

MVP 2005, it's a great game, haven't played 2K5, but MVP 2004 was great and they fixed most of the glitches from that including the "lefty bug".

[Sofa King Cheap]

Both Game Informer and EGM gave MVP 2005 higher scores.