First Revenge of the Sith reviews

[Ugamer_X]

No one has made a thread for this yet?...Or has it already been discussed in another thread? Either way, the first reviews are up and it seems promising.

http://www.rottentomatoes.com/m/star_wars_3/

[jacobv]

Even if it gets good reviews, I won't believe it's good until I see it for myself.

[Scahom1]

Very good to hear. After the critics trashed Episode 2, I was curious to see how they would react to 3.

[hobocorpses]

Phantom and Attack both got great reviews...even w/ all the "What you been smokin' Lucas?" stuff they were both pretty darn good movies, and i'm sure Sith will be too. It's just a matter of how well they do justice to the whole Star Wars genre.

[Xevious]

"Attack" was an improvement over "Phantom" although the dialog lines written for Anakin Skywalker were terrible.

[Friedle]

The book was an excellent read. Though, watching the clips in the game vs. the book it feels a little empty. There are so many cool lightsaber fights, I can't wait. I guess we'll find out for sure on the 19th.

[danny90044]

well phantom stunk, attack was cool (mostly cause of yoda), and i hope revenge is good and theres no jar jar gosh i hate him

[road3283]

Phantom and Attack both got great reviews...even w/ all the "What you been smokin' Lucas?" stuff they were both pretty darn good movies, and i'm sure Sith will be too. It's just a matter of how well they do justice to the whole Star Wars genre.

Just for the record, Ep. I and II got mixed reviews.

Metacritic Episode I (http://www.metacritic.com/video/titles/starwarsi)
Metacritic Episode II (http://www.metacritic.com/video/titles/starwarsii)

But I agree, I hope Revenge of the Sith does justice to the series.

[FriskyTanuki]

well phantom stunk, attack was cool (mostly cause of yoda), and i hope revenge is good and theres no jar jar gosh i hate him
I believe he only gets a few seconds on screen with no speaking at all.

[PenguinMaster]

The action was good in 1&2 and the acting was horrible. From the clips I've seen from 3, I expect the same.

[MorbidAngel4Life]

I hope it's good.

[Dead of Knight]

The book was an excellent read.

WTF? I couldn't read more than 30 pages of the book before putting it down. It is very poorly written. I read the whole graphic novel and the first 30 pages of the book (more since I didn't read past that?) were covered in one- two at most- pages of the graphic novel. I probably could have tolerated the poor writing a few years ago, but not now as I've been actually reading all the books assigned for school.

[Friedle]

WTF? I couldn't read more than 30 pages of the book before putting it down. It is very poorly written. I read the whole graphic novel and the first 30 pages of the book (more since I didn't read past that?) were covered in one- two at most- pages of the graphic novel. I probably could have tolerated the poor writing a few years ago, but not now as I've been actually reading all the books assigned for school.

You're right, Stover's writing isn't the best. Maybe I looked past it because it was Star Wars. The overall story was excellent in my opinion. The first couple chapeters were a smidge painful, but once Dooku entered it picked up.

[clockworkvictim]

I cant believe you guys liked ep 1 and 2. They were complete trash in my opinion. To each his own I suppose. The sad part is I know i'll end up going to this one even though I didn't like the others, and am not really a star wars fan by any means.

[zewone]

Sounds good. Can't wait to see it. Though I would have saw it with bad or good reviews.

[Javery]

If III is as good as I and II I'll be happy. They weren't the best movies ever made but I enjoyed them quite a bit.

[MaxBiaggi2]

Any comments on Anakin's Bush-like "If you're not with me, you're against me" statement while fighting Obi-Wan and Padme's "So this is how liberty dies. . . with thunderous applause" as Palpatine seizes control of the Senate for intergalatic "security" reasons?

[Javery]

Any comments on Anakin's Bush-like "If you're not with me, you're against me" statement while fighting Obi-Wan and Padme's "So this is how liberty dies. . . with thunderous applause" as Palpatine seizes control of the Senate for intergalatic "security" reasons?

That line is just dumb. Fucking hollywood morons. I don't give a shit what you think about anything - just entertain me. Nothing more.

[RAMSTORIA]

The action was good in 1&2 and the acting was horrible. From the clips I've seen from 3, I expect the same.
that sounds about right

[PsyClerk]

That line is just dumb. Fucking hollywood morons. I don't give a shit what you think about anything - just entertain me. Nothing more.

Nothing to add, just bears repeating.

[KrazyKefka]

Sounds good. Can't wait to see it. Though I would have saw it with bad or good reviews.

Same here. I'm definitely seeing it. Already have my tickets for the midnight showing here in town.

[thehuskerfan]

I have to see Ep. 3 too.

Its just one of those stories that you have to sum up, no matter how good or bad it is. (Hopefully Good!)

[Maizrim]

"Attack" was an improvement over "Phantom" although the dialog lines written for Anakin Skywalker were terrible.

Yeah, his lines were worse than those soap operas on Univision.

It is apparent that a young Mr. Lucas spent his Saturday nights alone.

[Moxio]

Now I have to see this.

[YeahRight13]

i cant wait till this movie comes out its goin to be sick

[willardhaven]

I don't understand the showtimes for this movie, it says 12:00 am on May 18, although the movie opens on the 19th.

Shouldn't it be listed as 12:00 am on May 19th?

Are theaters just assuming midnight means it's still PM?

[zewone]

I don't understand the showtimes for this movie, it says 12:00 am on May 18, although the movie opens on the 19th.

Shouldn't it be listed as 12:00 am on May 19th?

Are theaters just assuming midnight means it's still PM?

I believe some theaters just aren't as smart as we had hoped for them to be.

[Morrigan Lover]

This movie needs Christopher Walken in it.

[bmulligan]

"Five long years, your dad hid this lightsaber up his ass. Then when he died of dysentery, he gave me the lightsaber. I hid this uncomfortable piece of metal up my ass for two years. Then, after seven years, I was sent home to my family. And now, little man, I give the lightsaber to you."

[guessed]

Needs more cowbell.

[thehuskerfan]

Needs more cowbell.
Let's just have Chistopher Walken say it himself!


http://img28.photobucket.com/albums/v83/xboxbatman/walken.jpg