View Full Version : I hope you are all very proud of yourselves.
JSweeney
04-24-2004, 08:41 PM
While looking through a couple of threads over at Gamefaqs, I came across this:
http://cgi.gamefaqs.com/boards/genmessage.asp?board=213&topic=13775502
While the person is a moron, and known to be a major troll on the Gamefaqs boards, the legacy of the scam posts both past and present are begining to come back and haunt the site.
This makes CheapyD look bad, stifles support from legitimate businesses, and even presents the possibility of drawing even more theives and scammers to the board, thanks to the implication.
Cheapassgamer.com is very rapidly developing a reputation, and from the looks of that first post in that thread, it's beginging to be a very negative one.
SneakyPenguin
04-24-2004, 08:44 PM
hopefully most people will look at the site and find out that we really arent bad. but judging by the intelligence of most people, theyll just blindly follow mr. skull-fuck here.
Renzokuken
04-24-2004, 08:45 PM
what a filthy bastard...
Mr_hockey66
04-24-2004, 08:46 PM
It a positive for me! I love this site and promote it anytime I can! This place is my second home! Great deals (however I never playgames cause Im allways on here!) Great people and very funny posts! A+ in my book!
Mr_hockey66
04-24-2004, 08:48 PM
hopefully most people will look at the site and find out that we really arent bad. but judging by the intelligence of most people, theyll just blindly follow mr. skull-shaq-fu here.
Just means more deals for us! No I don't think it will hurt to bad! Wait A minute it must be CloudSpekk! With his other rippoff name!
punqsux
04-24-2004, 08:48 PM
haha, does it matter what a troll on a board that has topic like "Lets count to 500!" thinks?
SneakyPenguin
04-24-2004, 08:49 PM
haha, does it matter what a troll on a board that has topic like "Lets count to 500!" thinks?
we should strat that thread
ikik
bignick
04-24-2004, 08:51 PM
hopefully most people will look at the site and find out that we really arent bad. but judging by the intelligence of most people, theyll just blindly follow mr. skull-shaq-fu here.
Just means more deals for us! No I don't think it will hurt to bad! Wait A minute it must be CloudSpekk! With his other rippoff name!
Ha ha ha cloudspekks revenge!!! Who cares what they think.All companies care about it sales. I doubt they will care if walmart scams are on here. If anything, those companies read this stuff and change their policies.
Mr_hockey66
04-24-2004, 08:54 PM
I think there will be scams on any site. Fatwallet ign what evber they all have some topics on how to get free/cheaper stuff! Thats the whole point of this board right? Anways why is that if you save money which is smart on a same game that they buy for 50? That sound kinda dumb to me. Why pay 50 when you can 5 for the same thing? Makes sense to me. If they think its uncoll to save 40 bucks thats fine with me but that just proves your a dumbass if you won't save the money!
CaseyRyback
04-24-2004, 08:56 PM
You can tell he is not a regular here. The community is very aganist many of the things that he said, and most people that used to do illegal things like he said have stopped.
starman9000
04-24-2004, 08:58 PM
Hes got a point. We should all buy every new game that comes out so we can support the industry. Even if its just a repackaged sports game with new stats or an expansion level for a crappy PC game.
Personnally I support the industry by buying a couple of copies of each game and refusing to ever accept sale prices.
Mr_hockey66
04-24-2004, 09:00 PM
Its some one who got flamed on here their first week and is mad! Oh well! Anyone who comes in has to get a good flaming. Its like freshmen in highschool! You gota break them in.
Gothic Walrus
04-24-2004, 09:10 PM
Can you say rebutted? :D
http://cgi.gamefaqs.com/boards/detail.asp?board=213&topic=13775502&message=143277 740
The guy's a moron...and I'm hoping that he'll be humiliated before the topic vanishes.
alongx
04-24-2004, 09:11 PM
"I hope you're proud of yourselves"? That's a bit harsh, no? Most people on CAG don't fit under the category of gamers that this kid was criticizing. We just want cheap games. Not five-finger discounts.
EggViper
04-24-2004, 09:17 PM
that guys an idiot, so what if v try to get the best deals, its our right. and the thing is, because of this site im buying a lot of games i wouldve never bought. b4 i joined cag i wouldve just gone to the store and picked up a game, and it would still never b a $50 full price game cause i can't afford that. since i've joined this site i have been spending less on each game i buy, but i have been spending a lot more on games in general. so imo i dont think this sites hurting the economy in anyway, in my case its helping it.
Steggy
04-24-2004, 09:18 PM
Who cares what ANYONE at Gamefaqs would say. These are clearly the superior boards of the two. Im proud to be a CAG.
Mr_hockey66
04-24-2004, 09:18 PM
Right I dont steal the games but im not going to pay 50 for them either. If I can get it for 5 then Hmmm let me think about that one? Yep Ill take the cheaper one!
Mr. Anderson
04-24-2004, 09:19 PM
Dont' even listen to this guy, he's a complete douce. Brush your shoulders off, playas.
punqsux
04-24-2004, 09:23 PM
Dont' even listen to this guy, he's a complete douce. Brush your shoulders off, playas.
i had to get a quick flame in ^^
Mr_hockey66
04-24-2004, 09:25 PM
Dont mess with a pirate!
defender
04-24-2004, 09:25 PM
while his desciption may not be true for all CAGers...its not entirely wrong either...
read the posts here often enough and you can see the percentage of gamers he is talking about...personally there should be a ZERO tolerance to pirating and cheating stores but instead CAG has a low tolerance and the person generally gets a flaming... threads should get locked and users should get banned for mentioning the obviously illegal things they do
whether its 10% or 50% of the users here...it should be 0%
Mr_hockey66
04-24-2004, 09:27 PM
Just cause one person is commiting illegal activities shouldn't mean a theread should get locked right then! What and who would we have to flame then?
Beside cloudspekk!
defender
04-24-2004, 09:32 PM
occassionally a topic creaps up about copying dvds or where to get emulator roms..hey it happens
I think more users would get banned for individual posts than threads would be locked.
I know there are more than a few users here that pirate but dont really talk about it for fear of flaming..but you can read between the lines.
Mr_hockey66
04-24-2004, 09:47 PM
well in this age its just a given. People are going to do it and of course talk about it. Theres not really much to do about it. You can only ban that id right? Whats to say they just don't create a new acoount name and start them all over again. I think the Mods do a do job on locking legit illegal items. But whos to say because we use the free coupons from tru that we are not stealing? I mean techincally we are stealing too since we didn't pay for the hard bundle for those codes>..so i mean theres a thin line. Its all shades of gray no black or white. Some may thinks its stealing to use these codes and some not. Some think its stealsing to take games back to stores and some don't its just who Gray is the action to you. No I don't think blatin out stealing from a store is ok or any thing but whats the difference between cashing in on a store mistake online Ex: the 99 cent harry potter and such. Its still techincally stealing. so Its kinda werid to try and censor. Anyone see what i mean or Am I just rambling senseless again?
punqsux
04-24-2004, 09:50 PM
well in this age its just a given. People are going to do it and of course talk about it. Theres not really much to do about it. You can only ban that id right? Whats to say they just don't create a new acoount name and start them all over again. I think the Mods do a do job on locking legit illegal items. But whos to say because we use the free coupons from tru that we are not stealing? I mean techincally we are stealing too since we didn't pay for the hard bundle for those codes>..so i mean theres a thin line. Its all shades of gray no black or white. Some may thinks its stealing to use these codes and some not. Some think its stealsing to take games back to stores and some don't its just who Gray is the action to you. No I don't think blatin out stealing from a store is ok or any thing but whats the difference between cashing in on a store mistake online Ex: the 99 cent harry potter and such. Its steal techincally stealing. so Its kinda werid to try and censor. Anyone see what i mean or Am I just rambling senseless again?
i was with u in the first half, i was all like "yeah...YEAH!!" then i got lost you around harry potter
karmapolice
04-24-2004, 09:51 PM
occassionally a topic creaps up about copying dvds or where to get emulator roms..hey it happens
Im sorry defender :oops: I was a n00b...I didnt know any better :oops:
karmapolice
04-24-2004, 09:52 PM
my qoutes never work right....
Mr_hockey66
04-24-2004, 09:53 PM
On the Harry Potter I was talking about the .99 cent deal. May have been ment to be 9.99 We know that can't be right but we still cash in on it. So is that not stealing tooo?
JSweeney
04-24-2004, 09:55 PM
But whos to say because we use the free coupons from tru that we are not stealing? I mean techincally we are stealing too since we didn't pay for the hard bundle for those codes>..so i mean theres a thin line.
There is no thin line. That is theft. You aren't authorized to use those codes, yet you still are. It's theft.
Its all shades of gray no black or white.
Justification is in shades of grey. The law is black and white.
Some may thinks its stealing to use these codes and some not.
Just becuase you think it isn't or you can justify your theft to yourself doesn't mean that it isn't theft.
Some think its stealsing to take games back to stores and some don't
The walmart scam is theft and fraud, pure and simple. We've gone over that ad naseum.
its just who Gray is the action to you.
Justification is shades of grey. The law is black and white. There is no way around that.
No I don't think blatin out stealing from a store is ok or any thing but whats the difference between cashing in on a store mistake online Ex: the 99 cent harry potter and such.
Its steal techincally stealing.
Actually, you are wrong again. That isn't theft. That is a mismarked price.. and in many cases the stores won't honor them and just cancel orders. That, by the strict defenition of the law, isn't theft.
so Its kinda werid to try and censor. Anyone see what i mean or Am I just rambling senseless again?
Rambling and senseless again.
Mr_hockey66
04-24-2004, 09:56 PM
Thanks for clearing that up for me! :-)
And mr Sweeny are you going to sit here and tell me you didn't order any game from the Tru codes? Hmm i didn't think so.
punqsux
04-24-2004, 09:57 PM
On the Harry Potter I was talking about the .99 cent deal. May have been ment to be 9.99 We know that can't be right but we still cash in on it. So is that not stealing tooo?
totally not stealing, couldnt even be considered it, might be a mistake, but im sure if they needed to eb would cancel our orders w/o a 2nd thought
karmapolice
04-24-2004, 09:58 PM
Haha nice Mr. Hockey...nice...I love sarcasm...and JSweeney...I thought we were flaming gamefaqs and talking about people making crap for CAG...I didnt think we were flaming our own people...
JSweeney
04-24-2004, 09:59 PM
Thanks for clearing that up for me! :-)
And mr Sweeny are you going to sit here and tell me you didn't order nay game from the Tru codes? Hmm i dind't think so.
Yes, I will. I didn't order a single game with those TRU codes.
I didn't partake in the Reservation Rewards either.
punqsux
04-24-2004, 10:00 PM
Thanks for clearing that up for me! :-)
And mr Sweeny are you going to sit here and tell me you didn't order any game from the Tru codes? Hmm i didn't think so.
dude...youre on these boards enough to know, you NEVER call jsweeny out on ANYTHING because odd are he'll serve you
JSweeney
04-24-2004, 10:00 PM
Haha nice Mr. Hockey...nice...I love sarcasm...and JSweeney...I thought we were flaming gamefaqs and talking about people making crap for CAG...I didnt think we were flaming our own people...
There are times when it is more expedient to kill two birds with one stone.
Mr_hockey66
04-24-2004, 10:01 PM
Ok see Your a better person then me. Did I or the millions of others think it was stealling. Nope they didn't. Nor did I. There is the Shades of Gray I was talking about. Even the Cheap boss took part in these deals.
karmapolice
04-24-2004, 10:01 PM
Sweeney...You know you partook in an illegal activitie because you provided everyone with the codes and scams...
punqsux
04-24-2004, 10:03 PM
Sweeney...You know you partook in an illegal activitie because you provided everyone with the codes and scams...
what are you talking about?
JSweeney
04-24-2004, 10:04 PM
Sweeney...You know you partook in an illegal activitie because you provided everyone with the codes and scams...
Just because I am part of the board does not mean that I am party to all actions that take place upon it. To suggest that would be laughable...
that would be like holding bebop, metroidkiller and Mightslacker culpable for cloudspeckk ripping them off.
karmapolice
04-24-2004, 10:06 PM
No im saying you providing everyone codes and scams is just as bad as the people who used them...
punqsux
04-24-2004, 10:07 PM
No im saying you providing everyone codes and scams is just as bad as the people who used them...
make it stop!
JSweeney
04-24-2004, 10:08 PM
What in the world are you talking about?
Mr_hockey66
04-24-2004, 10:09 PM
Now i can taking a good flaming like everyone eles so no prob but just beacuse you don't think its right or wrong dosn't mean everyone else thinks the same way as you. Im glad you didn't take part in something you felt was wrong. I didn't fill it was so I took part in it! Thats were the shades of gray come in. Tru could have stopped us from using them to but they didn't either cause they wanted the money and bussiness just the same.
Nirvanaguy777
04-24-2004, 10:10 PM
that guy on gamefaqs is ignorant, right Michael
Michael: Yes ignornat, hes bein ignorant
JSweeney
04-24-2004, 10:13 PM
Now i can taking a good flaming like everyone eles so no prob but just beacuse you don't think its right or wrong dosn't mean everyone else thinks the same way as you. Im glad you didn't take part in something you felt was wrong. I didn't fill it was so I took part in it!
Just because you didn't think or feel it was wrong, doesn't mean it wasn't.
Thats were the shades of gray come in.
Right, Wrong, Legal, Illegal are all absolutes. There are no shades of grey where absolutes are concered. Justification is what creates the black and white. You can think something is justified, but that doesn't make it right.
Tru could have stopped us from using them to but they didn't either cause they wanted the money and bussiness just the same
That is you trying to justify it right there. It doesn't change the fact that it wasn't right. You didn't buy the item required to get the code. You weren't authorized to use the code. It was wrong.
karmapolice
04-24-2004, 10:14 PM
Blah Blah...something was here
Mr_hockey66
04-24-2004, 10:18 PM
Ok thanks again god I mean sweeny
Wrong in your book. Not everyoneles book! Thanks for playing!
Do you want an award or a pat on the back??? Thats great you didn't take part. So are you just here to talk? You have never took part in a deal?
JSweeney
04-24-2004, 10:19 PM
:D
Edited. That post read a little to harsh.
CaseyRyback
04-24-2004, 10:20 PM
could someone enlighten me on these TRU coupons? I am just wondering what everyone is talking about
SneakyPenguin
04-24-2004, 10:20 PM
why dont you two take it to the flame thread? let this topic STAY on topic.
punqsux
04-24-2004, 10:21 PM
could someone enlighten me on these TRU coupons? I am just wondering what everyone is talking about
the tru online coupons for like the hulk, i-ninja, summer volleyball
Mr_hockey66
04-24-2004, 10:22 PM
Yes I can. I understand thats why I brought up the point in the first place! Its still stealling! No matter what thats why its hard to censor and moderate! Geez.. Does it make any more difference then piracy nope! Then stealling from a store. not really. Shades of Gray!
JSweeney
04-24-2004, 10:22 PM
could someone enlighten me on these TRU coupons? I am just wondering what everyone is talking about
Back in the long, long ago, TRU offered a promo where they would sell games for a reduced price if you purchased a console. After you purchased the console online, they would provide you with a coupon code that would allow you that reduced price.
Some people got those codes and shared them around with others.
punqsux
04-24-2004, 10:24 PM
could someone enlighten me on these TRU coupons? I am just wondering what everyone is talking about
Back in the long, long ago, TRU offered a promo where they would sell games for a reduced price if you purchased a console. After you purchased the console online, they would provide you with a coupon code that would allow you that reduced price.
Some people got those codes and shared them around with others.
unless im mistaken i believe it was a book of codes that came bundled with ps2 around the holidays
CaseyRyback
04-24-2004, 10:24 PM
then yea that is wrong. I think TRU should use more protection to avoid this, but them not providing security on thier stuff does not mean they should be ripped off.
Mr_hockey66
04-24-2004, 10:26 PM
Just to clear this up! Sweeny I have no probs with you! I jsut like to debate as much as you...and YOu are the king of debate so its kinda fun. i mean no ill will! But its just so much fun to argue with you!
JSweeney
04-24-2004, 10:27 PM
I understand that completely.
That's exactly why I went back and edited out one of the posts...
I felt it read a bit to harshly, and there is really no call for that.
punqsux
04-24-2004, 10:28 PM
just curious, does anyone know the origin of the legendary aff25 code?
Gothic Walrus
04-24-2004, 10:29 PM
No im saying you providing everyone codes and scams is just as bad as the people who used them...
Link?
If you can't prove it, shut the fuck up.
JSweeney
04-24-2004, 10:30 PM
Judging by the nomenclature, I would assume it would be something like an affilate code, but as for where it really comes from, I have no idea.
karmapolice
04-24-2004, 10:32 PM
gothic...you obvoisly came in too late to see my appology because I took it out because it asked a question and i didnt want to get anyone in trouble so i deleted it...notice the "blah blah" part...thats where it was...
Mr_hockey66
04-24-2004, 10:32 PM
You don't have to edit for me! Like I said I can take a joke! If you can't take the heat then stay out of the kitchen! But yes I do agree wiuth you it is still stealing no matter what. Did I get in on these deals off course but would I walk into a store and put a game in my pants and walk out HELL NO. Did I realize it was stealing at the time? Yes and no. Compmanies do these sorts of things to clearence items and to get bussiness whence the coupon. They take a loss to get more bussiness. So Its kinda strange. After I found out that Its a bundle you realize you just stole something. The whole shades of gray thing.
karmapolice
04-24-2004, 10:37 PM
sweeney...just a question...do you think the aff25 is "illegal" or imoral? JW
punqsux
04-24-2004, 10:39 PM
sweeney...just a question...do you think the aff25 is "illegal" or imoral? JW
thats y i asked...i started a seperate thread about it, hopefully someone knows where it came from
Gothic Walrus
04-24-2004, 10:40 PM
gothic...you obvoisly came in too late to see my appology because I took it out because it asked a question and i didnt want to get anyone in trouble so i deleted it...notice the "blah blah" part...thats where it was...
Okay then...in that case, I apologize.
JSweeney
04-24-2004, 10:41 PM
No idea. I have no idea where it comes from. That's also why I've never used it.
CaseyRyback
04-24-2004, 10:42 PM
I have used it the two or so times I was allowed and mainly use the coupons on EB's pre-played page instead of making a new account
karmapolice
04-24-2004, 10:43 PM
Perfectly alright...and by the way i was going on about nothing because I havent had alot of sleep and dont know which way is up...that was directed to gothic (didnt want Sweeney to go off on another flame) jp
Mr_hockey66
04-24-2004, 10:44 PM
You are pillar of light my friend! Did you play kotor btw? I bet you were a darkside all the way through! Don't worry i won't tell anyone! :-) JK
karmapolice
04-24-2004, 10:45 PM
are you saying I can only use AFF25 once? Actually thats prolly all ill use it because im gunna buy abunch of GC games ive missed out on...So nvm
karmapolice
04-24-2004, 10:46 PM
I was darkside :( i felt kinda bad too...I guess thats what I get
punqsux
04-24-2004, 10:50 PM
ya know, now that i think about it, we do do alot of illegal stuff here
SneakyPenguin
04-24-2004, 10:51 PM
ya know, now that i think about it, we do do alot of illegal stuff here
what was that? im sorry i was busy playing mame..
jk :lol:
karmapolice
04-24-2004, 10:52 PM
Sure do...I mean...I dont!... :/
karmapolice
04-24-2004, 10:53 PM
I find mame a stretch...I mean...Who is willing to fork over thousands of dollars to play an arcade game...I know you can get the crappy console versions...but thats not ALL of the arcade games...Im not about getting pirated games but when it comes to thou$ands of dollars...thats a stretch
punqsux
04-24-2004, 10:56 PM
ya know, now that i think about it, we do do alot of illegal stuff here
what was that? im sorry i was busy playing mame..
jk :lol:
im sure you have the arcade machines, right?
:wink:
CaseyRyback
04-24-2004, 10:57 PM
You are pillar of light my friend! Did you play kotor btw? I bet you were a darkside all the way through! Don't worry i won't tell anyone! :-) JK
No I did not play the dark side. If someone really pissed me off I would do something to them (like the girl that was on the dark side on the world with all the Jedi) but aside from her, I usually played on the light side
SneakyPenguin
04-24-2004, 10:57 PM
ya know, now that i think about it, we do do alot of illegal stuff here
what was that? im sorry i was busy playing mame..
jk :lol:
im sure you have the arcade machines, right?
:wink:
as do you :wink:
Quackzilla
04-24-2004, 11:23 PM
What were you doing on gamefaqs anyway, you post horny forum crawler.
defender
04-25-2004, 03:44 AM
threads should get locked and users should get banned for mentioning the obviously illegal things they do
I stated OBVIOUSLY ILLEGAL ....
and as others have argued...coupons arent illegal.
obvious illegal activities include ROM downloads, backups, copies, burns, and store returns when it wasnt purchased at the store (thats fraud)
also not just a users account to get banned but also their IP address
Mr_hockey66
04-25-2004, 10:10 AM
Backups are legal. Just not giving those backups out to others. But thats what happens under the banner of "backup" I do have burns and copied cds on my CPu however I have purchased every cd I have on it. I just don't like to have to keep switching cds so I put the songs to back up format to have on the CPu and then my mp3 file. But i have or had the cd at time i put it on the CPU.
CheapyD
04-25-2004, 10:41 AM
casual gamers almost always buy new games at places like best buy, fry's, walmart etc... They also dont trade in gameZ hurting video game sales.
Hardcore gamerZ either pirate games, buy used, trade in games,or scour the net looking for the worlds cheapest copy of (game X) just to save $4.33, courtesy of cheapassgamer. Sometimes they scheme like the walmart return scam. They rarely ever buy games they want new like with rez and wait for it to go on sale, or buy used. And then they complain why companies dont make enough hardcore games,and why they cater to casuals.
---
I'm back with a 100% more in your face attitude.
XBOX own it, because without it your PWNED.
I don't see anything bad about that. People who buy lots of games want to save money. He is referring to hardcore gamers, not CAGs when mentioning walmart returns. Also, his signature is extremely lame.
Regarding the TRU coupons:
Associates may post coupon codes on their Web site with one exception. All coupon codes beginning with "MAP" are restricted and cannot be posted by Associates. All other codes are available to post. If one of our partners decides at some point to restrict a code that does not fall under the "MAP" policy, we will notify you via email.
No email yet...
EDIT: I forgot...
The legend of AFF25
Its a 100% legitimate coupon code delivered through EBgames' affiliate program, created for websites like CAG.
JSweeney
04-25-2004, 11:26 AM
I don't see anything bad about that. People who buy lots of games want to save money. He is referring to hardcore gamers, not CAGs when mentioning walmart returns. Also, his signature is extremely lame.
Yeah, the guy is entirely lame, and a huge idiot to boot. It's just that it's vexing to see the CAG name tossed around where such things are talked about. Considering the proximity of both ideas in the statement, and the writers obvious lack of writing ability, I read into it a little and saw that as somewhat of an attack... and I hate when things like that are tossed around making this site sound like a place of ill repute when yourself, most of the posters here, and myself work so hard to provide such and unfriendly enviornment for those types of scams and fraud.
Before anyone else posts about the thread topic... it wasn't designed as an implication of blame, rather as just a way to get your attention and have you look in the thread, and see that there are some morons out there talking trash about CAG.
Regarding the TRU coupons:
Associates may post coupon codes on their Web site with one exception. All coupon codes beginning with "MAP" are restricted and cannot be posted by Associates. All other codes are available to post. If one of our partners decides at some point to restrict a code that does not fall under the "MAP" policy, we will notify you via email.
No email yet...
That's great to hear. I'm not going to object about that one anymore, as you obviously did all of the groundwork before letting that one get posted and then put up on the front page. It is really great you diligent you are about these things Cheapy, as I'd hate for accusations of impropriety on your part to damage the reputation of the site, or have any ill effect on the userbase. (Based on what you've done in the past, I highly doubt that would ever happen.)
The legend of AFF25
Its a 100% legitimate coupon code delivered through EBgames' affiliate program, created for websites like CAG.
That's great to hear. I'll start using it as of right now.
punqsux
04-25-2004, 04:32 PM
its nice to know that those tru codes are on the level, way to do your homework cheapy!, and thanks for clearing up the aff25 code =o)
defender
04-25-2004, 04:36 PM
Backups are legal. Just not giving those backups out to others. But thats what happens under the banner of "backup" I do have burns and copied cds on my CPu however I have purchased every cd I have on it. I just don't like to have to keep switching cds so I put the songs to back up format to have on the CPu and then my mp3 file. But i have or had the cd at time i put it on the CPU.
this is a popular misconception and no longer true after the DMCA was put into effect..it was grey area until the DMCA which clearly makes it illegal despite anything you can say...
speak to an entertainment lawyer or a copyright lawyer they can confirm this
oh and if you are talking about music...that a bit different and the DMCA deals with that.. I am referring to software which games are considered..since this is a games site I dont believe music discussion here is a big deal
punqsux
04-25-2004, 04:39 PM
Backups are legal. Just not giving those backups out to others. But thats what happens under the banner of "backup" I do have burns and copied cds on my CPu however I have purchased every cd I have on it. I just don't like to have to keep switching cds so I put the songs to back up format to have on the CPu and then my mp3 file. But i have or had the cd at time i put it on the CPU.
this is a popular misconception and no longer true after the DMCA was put into effect..it was grey area until the DMCA which clearly makes it illegal despite anything you can say...
speak to an entertainment lawyer or a copyright lawyer they can confirm this
oh and if you are talking about music...that a bit different and the DMCA deals with that.. I am referring to software which games are considered..since this is a games site I dont believe music discussion here is a big deal
wait, backing up cds to mp3s is illegal? then how are mp3 players and programs like realone and music match legal?
magilacudy
04-25-2004, 04:42 PM
The thread's been deleted. I assume it was about pirating/piracy/punqsux argg matey somehow.
Quackzilla
04-25-2004, 05:04 PM
Backups are legal. Just not giving those backups out to others. But thats what happens under the banner of "backup" I do have burns and copied cds on my CPu however I have purchased every cd I have on it. I just don't like to have to keep switching cds so I put the songs to back up format to have on the CPu and then my mp3 file. But i have or had the cd at time i put it on the CPU.
How do you put a CD on a central processing unit?
punqsux
04-25-2004, 05:06 PM
The thread's been deleted. I assume it was about pirating/piracy/punqsux argg matey somehow.
yaar, t'was a thread bashing cheap gamers
(cheapy quoted the origional post)
magilacudy
04-25-2004, 05:14 PM
I don't get what his point was? I don't understand how saving money by looking for the cheapest price could be considered equal to pirating or scamming. Or how not trading in games would hurt video game sales?
That makes me just a little bit mad. Someone probably already said it, but I wouldn't be suprised if this dude happened to be CloudSpekk.
defender
04-25-2004, 08:06 PM
wait, backing up cds to mp3s is illegal? then how are mp3 players and programs like realone and music match legal?
hey Punqsux- read this paragraph again...
oh and if you are talking about music...that a bit different and the DMCA deals with that.. I am referring to software which games are considered..since this is a games site I dont believe music discussion here is a big deal
karmapolice
04-26-2004, 06:42 PM
Actually you are allowed to make ONE backup copy of any DVD,CD,or game(if you have the means to do so).That one backup is for you and only you and if you distrubute it in any way then it becomes illegal.Other than that you can make one copy of anything you own and you are doing something perfectly legal. Video games are now going to start having an FBI Warning at the begining of games and CD's will now have FBI warnings saying the crap about distrobution and what not, because before it was much harder for componies to prosocute people on pirating videogames (other than copy write laws). I am not sure when this FBI Warning is going into effect but expect it sometime in the near future