Originally Posted by masterd919

I just bought a game online and it came in one of those generic cases...Needless to say I'll be walking in tomorrow and telling them to take it back. That is a deal-breaker for me. Last gen I wouldn't mind, but I have a ton of games and that stands out to me. I get OCD with that stuff. Plus, what happened to the original case? Did someone eat it? It boggles me how someone can trade in a disc only. That should never been considered "good condition" either....