I liked the writing, setting and characters in RDR but I just can't -play- it.
From the tapping -x- to get your horse to sprint (but don't tap too much!) mechanic, to the combat controls.
No lock-on? No icon or health bar over someone-one's head so I can tell who I am shooting at?
Which button's shoot? Draw? Dodge?
Oh, I'm dead again.
I'll protect everyone....with my TACTICS!