You seem heavily invested in the 360 already, so fixing it is an ok option. But PS3 has soooo many great exclusives out of the FPS genre that you can get on the cheap if you're barely jumping on board. You can get the cheap packs they have like God of War, infamous, and Uncharted. Free online. Starship Troopers is awesome on blu ray. For less than 20 bucks you can score the Heavy Rain: Director's Cut, there's a list of stuff you can catch up on with ps3. When you get a GOTY edition or Complete edition, the extra stuff is usually on the disc NOT a voucher, and no more swapping discs if you care about that lol. This year, Last of Us and Beyond:Two Souls is coming out. PS3 is a slam dunk choice.