Just got back and my printout worked like a charm. The Assistant Manager even read the entire coupon before scanning it.
I couldn't get the 20% bonus for putting a pre-order down on Madden/NCAA though. I'm sure I could have made a stink about it but I was happy with the $15 bonus! Thanks again OP.
Also there is another cardboard gift card going around that gives you $40 trade in credit on NCAA 09 if you preorder/purchase Madden 09. This is for the 360 & PS3 versions. The Wii version gives you $30 credit. I probably won't take advantage of this offer, but if you are the type of gamer that buys NCAA just to hold you over until Madden gets out, $44 ($40+edge) in credit isn't a bad deal. I'll try to get a scan up.