Originally Posted by lebkin
I have heard this argument before, that it is CheapyD and the CAGCast's job to cover all games equally. I do not agree. I think the job of the CAGCast is to be entertaining. I would much rather have CheapyD talk to me about the games he enjoyed and why, rather than things he is struggling to get through just to make listeners happy. He is better to listen to when he's happy about gaming.
It’s not that entertaining to hear about the same games for the same systems week in and week out. Given the amount of positive feedback Shipwreck is getting, it seems pretty clear that the limited gaming palette of the hosts is getting boring. Cheapy himself buys all sorts of shit just to “talk about on the show”, so it seems to the he recognizes that due diligence should be a part of the show (even if he doesn’t always practice it).
That said, everything outside the game talk is great.