Originally Posted by emjaymj

I have to agree, SMG1 was unbelievable. SMG2 MIGHT be a better game, but to call it inferior is still ridiculous. I'm the kind of guy that gets impatient with games and often doesn't even finish them. It's also rare that I play a single-player game more than once.

I not only "beat" SMG by defeating Bowser, I 100%ed it with Mario, and with then Luigi unlocked, IMMEDIATELY 100%ed the game again, obtaining the new bonus stars as well. If SMG2 is just as good or even better, it just means we have 2 incredible games, and calling either of them "inferior" is hugely misleading when both games occupy a top 3 spot on gamerankings.com