Respectfully, I can't disagree more; I found Extraction one of the more engaging rail-shooters on the Wii, though it helps that I was in the strange slice of people who 1) Owns both a Wii and a 360 or PS3, 2) Loved the crap out of the original Dead Space, and 3) Likes rail-shooters. I also like HOTD: Overkill, and it's probably a better straight-up light gun game, but the combination of the lore/setting of Dead Space, the light RPG-ish customization and just the more methodical pacing of the game all clicked with me.

I picked Extraction up last Black Friday, actually, when it was $25, and really liked it. At this price I'd recommend it for anyone who likes rail-shooters and doesn't mind something a bit more narrative-focused.