Wombat on Backbreaker:
"It's not a good game."
"It's a really good [$5 to $8] Game"
Make up your mind, Wombat.
The only reason I can see for people hating Burnout Crash before even playing it is the Wind Waker effect, where they can't stand seeing a new art style for a familiar game.
I'm going to take a wild guess that Keiji Inafune leaving Capcom is one of the reasons that they're hesitant to push for more Mega Man since he created the series and was the main guy behind Universe and Legend 3. They should've finished up the paid demo for Mega Man Legends 3, released it on 3DS, then cancelled it so that they could blame the fans and take far less heat than they are now.
I wouldn't exactly compare a puzzle game, Catherine, to Demon's Souls, an action-RPG, in terms of difficulty. The launch Japanese version was supposed to be really hard, but they've since updated it to make it a bit easier. I also have to laugh about calling people that are interested in Catherine nerds but had to talk about Harry Potter, X-Men, Captain America, Robot Chicken Star Wars, Voltron, a space combat sim on the Xbox 360, and the NPDs.
From what I've read, XBL Indie Game developers get a ready-to-distribute executible of their games for the PC that they do what they want with it. It seems like it would've been in their best interest to lock up PC versions for GFW Live instead of letting them run off to Steam or any other competing PC service.
I'm surprised that you guys didn't go off on a GOTY edition for a game that's only been out for a few months and hasn't even been up for any awards yet.