Advertisement

Register for free to remove this ad

My biggest gripe with the series finale was that they killed Sisko. Only time the captain of the show has ever been killed off like that. Hell, kill Janeway if you just gotta kill a captain.

Originally Posted by Clak My biggest gripe with the series finale was that they killed Sisko. Only time the captain of the show has ever been killed off like that. Hell, kill Janeway if you just gotta kill a captain.

She did die a few times...only to be brought back via Voyager's Reset button.......god damn reset button :(

I don't think Sisko died remember........he's with the Prophets.

Sisko didn't die! He became an energy being and moved into the wormhole.

The re-launch novels are pretty great stuff. Sisko's return is somewhat epic! Unrelated to Sisko, even if you're not a licensed fiction reader, I suggest the Garek book A Stitch in Time.

DS9 was supposed to get a movie which went into all that but of course, never happened.

They did take shortcuts in the last season. Like how they destroyed the Defiant and said wait a minute, we have all these special effects shots in the can already, we need to bring the ship back with the same name and number.

Watch Babylon 5 if you haven't, they'll show you how long story arcs and plot points set up years in advance are done.

Originally Posted by dafoomie DS9 was supposed to get a movie which went into all that but of course, never happened. They did take shortcuts in the last season. Like how they destroyed the Defiant and said wait a minute, we have all these special effects shots in the can already, we need to bring the ship back with the same name and number. Watch Babylon 5 if you haven't, they'll show you how long story arcs and plot points set up years in advance are done.

Voyager was to get a movie as well...

They already made a Gilligan's Island movie, no need for a second.

Funny clip of Stewart getting roasted.

http://tv.yahoo.com/news/the--star-t...200755678.html

Just a reminder folks that the two episode season 2 event is tonight at 7pm in select theaters. My wife and I are going.....lets hope that I can make a trekker out of her with these two episodes...and NO I AM NOT GETTING OUT OF MY SEAT TO GET A REFILL LOL!

Anyways.....looks like BB will have season 2 BR for 65 dollars next week.... A 5 dollar increase from season 1 is not bad at all! I can use my 100 dollar GC to help pay for that, Nemo, Batman and Ted.

I realize it's a fairly old series, but I'm 6 episodes away from finishing DS9 and would have appreciated some spoiler tags regarding Sisko's fate. I know not all plot details can be treated with care given the age of these series, but it's a pretty crucial and central detail regarding a main character. Hadn't been to the thread in awhile and in the past I'd seen a bit more discretion regarding that kinda stuff.

Aside from that, I've been enjoying DS9 and I can see why so many people (including a close friend of mine) regard it as their favorite Trek.

Darth Vader also dies.

Originally Posted by Clak Darth Vader also dies.

And Voyager gets back to Earth! Crazy, right?

Anyway, johnnypark, don't worry about it -- most of what has been said is vague enough that nothing much has been spoiled.

Just in case, though, the thing that disappointed me the most was the final confrontation with Dukat. I've talked about this before, but that just struck me as the biggest anticlimax ever.

All those weeks of Dukat and Winn scheming, all the stuff with the Prophets vs. the Pah Wraiths, all the "He is the Sisko" stuff boiled down to the Prophets needing someone to push Dukat off a cliff. They would have been better off with a bulldozer.

Originally Posted by ITDEFX oh get over it. It was pretty good.

I think this is the frustrating part. It was pretty good. It should have been amazing. It should have been great. The last season was lazy in a lot of ways. They had all that time to decide what to do with all the players and I honestly think they could have come up with something better.

It is yet another indication that there never was much long-term planning on any Trek show, even though that's the very thing that made DS9 thrive. I'm still kind of astonished that they kept going right through to the very last episode with the war and the prophets and all that. They left no time for closure or goodbyes or wrapping things up, except for that miserable montage. That's Writing 101 right there, for both things. Always have a denoument. If you have to use a montage, you're doing it wrong and you're basically admitting you have no idea what to do and all your best material came way before.

I do think it was a matter of priorities. It was (incomprehensibly) important to give the Ferengi some kind of resolution, and they budgeted time for such pressing matters as Ezri's family drama and holodeck baseball. I do wish someone had thought to budget some time for less important things like Garak and Kira and the fates of both Cardassia and Bajor.

I do think they should get a pass for Ezri Dax. There really wasn't much they could do. Casting changes like that interrupt the flow and the vibe and can make hash of a series, and there isn't really time to build up the new character and take her somewhere interesting in the final season. This happened to Babylon 5, too. I know I believe that Season 5 would have been a lot better had Claudia Christian not departed.

Ezri wasn't the fault of the actress, who did everything she could. I could blame the writers, but I think they tried. It just wasn't going to be something that was ever going to be great. It's a minor accomplishment that it wasn't awful, and Nicole de Boer deserves a gold star for making the best of a bad situation.

Just came back from the Fanthom Event. The picture quality wasn't that great.... I noticed a LOT of purple fringing throughout both episodes. The perspective of the cube was NOT fixed :( Dialog mix was low, but sound effects and music were high.
The measure of a man extended cut was WELL DONE. Well worth watching. I won't spoil it but there is a scene in Ten Forward of that episode that just really made everyone laugh.

Before the event they had some documentary about the remastering process and so on.

The roundtable preview was pretty good. The outtakes were hilarious.

oh yeah I forgot how hot Ensign Sonya Gomez was in Q Who.


Really too bad her character was never developed :(

They showed a trailer for the Season 3 BR. It looks really good.. No time frame though.

There were no freebees sadly.

Originally Posted by ITDEFX They showed a trailer for the Season 3 BR. It looks really good.. No time frame though.

Since they released two seasons across a few months, I'd guess March or April 2013 for S3, July/August for S4 and December for S5.

Assuming they were working on the seasons in some sense of staggered parallel development.

Originally Posted by ITDEFX Anyways.....looks like BB will have season 2 BR for 65 dollars next week.... A 5 dollar increase from season 1 is not bad at all! I can use my 100 dollar GC to help pay for that, Nemo, Batman and Ted.

Awesome news. I've been waiting to see Best Buy's price. Folks, I hope it goes without saying to submit a price alert to Amazon.

I too went to the showing. I echo pretty much everything ITDEFX said. Season 3 looks incredible-glorious thanks to the geniuses at CBS-Digital... I can only hope they don't try to rush the further seasons by continuing to use the other team. At the moment, NOTHING beyond season 3 has been officially scheduled (though as Shrike notes, they did mention their hope to stagger the development between the two teams to get the sets out quicker), so there is still time for CBS to come to their senses, and not rush things.

Love most of the deleted scenes.
Extra scene with Geordi was touching, the scene in Ten-Forward ITDEFX alludes to wonderful and hilarious.

One scene in particular, though...
I think the only scene that doesn't fit in and is a detriment to the episode is Riker coming in during Picard's fencing lesson to boast about how he was going to try his best, and not pull any punches. The original cut of the episode PERFECTLY encapsulates Riker's natural competitive nature, and his complete unwillingless to do something that could hurt his friend and comrade-- the scene where he's viewing Data's schematics, and a gleeful smile erupts on his face when he realizes he has the crucial element needed for his prosecution. Almost immediately, he feels guilty and the shit eating grin evaporates. The boasting scene with Picard that takes place before that is just out of place with what Riker's character is feeling-- any sort of pride about the proceeding to decide his friend's fate could and should only take place pretty much as they depicted. IMHO, of course.

Overall though, make sure you see the extended cut of Measure of a Man. Buy the set, rent the set, borrow the disk from your friend. Something. It's truly a wonderful watch.

Originally Posted by shrike4242 Since they released two seasons across a few months, I'd guess March or April 2013 for S3, July/August for S4 and December for S5. Assuming they were working on the seasons in some sense of staggered parallel development.

Oh yeah..you are right...so March/April. I really hope Enterprise does not come out that same day or else my wallet is gonna be hurting :(

Originally Posted by Friend of Sonic Awesome news. I've been waiting to see Best Buy's price. Folks, I hope it goes without saying to submit a price alert to Amazon. I too went to the showing. I echo pretty much everything ITDEFX said. Season 3 looks incredible-glorious thanks to the geniuses at CBS-Digital... I can only hope they don't try to rush the further seasons by continuing to use the other team. At the moment, NOTHING beyond season 3 has been officially scheduled (though as Shrike notes, they did mention their hope to stagger the development between the two teams to get the sets out quicker), so there is still time for CBS to come to their senses, and not rush things. Love most of the deleted scenes. Extra scene with Geordi was touching, the scene in Ten-Forward ITDEFX alludes to wonderful and hilarious. One scene in particular, though... I think the only scene that doesn't fit in and is a detriment to the episode is Riker coming in during Picard's fencing lesson to boast about how he was going to try his best, and not pull any punches. The original cut of the episode PERFECTLY encapsulates Riker's natural competitive nature, and his complete unwillingless to do something that could hurt his friend and comrade-- the scene where he's viewing Data's schematics, and a gleeful smile erupts on his face when he realizes he has the crucial element needed for his prosecution. Almost immediately, he feels guilty and the shit eating grin evaporates. The boasting scene with Picard that takes place before that is just out of place with what Riker's character is feeling-- any sort of pride about the proceeding to decide his friend's fate could and should only take place pretty much as they depicted. IMHO, of course. Overall though, make sure you see the extended cut of Measure of a Man. Buy the set, rent the set, borrow the disk from your friend. Something. It's truly a wonderful watch.

I really think the Q Who episode needed more effects touch up. They got a bit lazy and reused that weird computer animation of the borg ship rebuilding itself. They could have done something in that scene where Data was looking at a wall with a tricorder and then telling everyone else that the ship is being repaired. Even some minor CG would have helped that scene.

I really enjoyed the event last night and am hoping they'll do one for season 3 (I think they will...two episodes were previewed at end). There weren't any glaring issues that made the showing unbearable but it did take what seemed like forever to go through all of Fathom event commercials and it cut off one of the interviews.

The Measure of a Man was like you guys mentioned: amazing. I love pretty much anything showcasing Data because I'm a big fan of the character. It was pretty cool to see the Borg ship on the big screen again but I do agree with ITDEFX that they should have touched it up a bit more.

I am guessing "Sins of the Father"....well because you know they keep on praising the shit out of it for one the episodes and of course Yesterday's enterprise. If they don't have YE on the list...I'm gonna be pissed..but then again I most likely am going to be teaching that night ...sigh...can't take a day off lol.

I wonder though... Are they going to do BOBW part 1 and 2 back to back as a movie per say? Then again would you rather have just part 1 or YE?

Something that randomly bothered me recently...

In the Star Trek Voyager Episode Learning Curve (the one where the 4 Maqius crew members had to test with Tuxok)...

...Tuxok requires them to get in 100% correct dress code, removing Bajorin ear piece, a necklace, etc.

How was Worf allowed to be out of dress code for 7 seasons?

Picard was far less strict on things like dress code.

Deanna is a great example. She was out of uniform for something like five seasons until Jellico came aboard and yelled at her.

Originally Posted by UncleBob Picard was far less strict on things like dress code. Deanna is a great example. She was out of uniform for something like five seasons until Jellico came aboard and yelled at her.

Originally Posted by Tony Stark Something that randomly bothered me recently... In the Star Trek Voyager Episode Learning Curve (the one where the 4 Maqius crew members had to test with Tuxok)... ...Tuxok requires them to get in 100% correct dress code, removing Bajorin ear piece, a necklace, etc. How was Worf allowed to be out of dress code for 7 seasons?

Simple......sex sells............. Plus do you really want to tell Worf he can't wear his family sash ? He would kill you in a second.