http://www.amazon.com/Silent-Hill-Do.../dp/B003O6G47U

I got this a while ago on that BB DOTD. I got to a part, got lost and confused, and sold it. Game blows.

To be honest I like where they were going with the game and that they seemed to try to make it good, but they failed pretty hard and as such the game is pretty much trash. I would recommend it at a <$5 price but this is still too high. This is coming from a non-diehard Silent Hill fan.

It's been this price for about 6 weeks now.

Loved the game except for the OtherWorld levels. They felt like one of those haunted house features in an amusement park.

Originally Posted by Capocci 007 I got this a while ago on that BB DOTD. I got to a part, got lost and confused, and sold it. Game blows.

Same here. It was creepy as hell in the abandoned houses. That was the only good thing it had going for it, it was pretty bad otherwise. Is homecoming any better?

silent hill games have been hit or miss this gen of consoles. ill wait for 10$ or less and give this game a try

Originally Posted by Vap Same here. It was creepy as hell in the abandoned houses. That was the only good thing it had going for it, it was pretty bad otherwise. Is homecoming any better?

Homecoming is a lot worse.

Originally Posted by strait edge follower silent hill games have been hit or miss this gen of consoles. ill wait for 10$ or less and give this game a try

Guess you missed the $9.99 PS3 version(3D compatible) at Amazon.

Originally Posted by ChunLiBarbie Guess you missed the $9.99 PS3 version(3D compatible) at Amazon.

when was this sale ? oh well it will hit that price again soon i bet

Originally Posted by Why_So_Serious Homecoming is a lot worse.

This is awesome news. I LOVED Homecoming. I played through it twice.

Originally Posted by strait edge follower when was this sale ? oh well it will hit that price again soon i bet

December.

I think Homecoming & Downpour are the best in the series. I am serious.

I liked the hour and a half or so I played of Homecoming.

Though I do find it weird the protag never gets around to asking anyone he meets "So, how long has this city had a spontaneous sinkhole and flesh mangled monster problem?"

Originally Posted by Capocci 007 I got this a while ago on that BB DOTD. I got to a part, got lost and confused, and sold it. Game blows.

I got to that part, I didn't get lost or confused, and finished it. Game doesn't blow.

Seriously though I found the enemies lacking and uninspired but as far as Silent Hill the town goes, it was, as far as I'm concerned, the best so far.

This game is a hot mess.

Not that you have to be a diehard Silent Hill fan to appreciate the games but you have to at least understand them. I feel like most people that totally trash the recent SH games, just don't understand what SH is about.

I haven't played Downpour, I've also been waiting for $10 since I missed the last Amazon sale...but I think homecoming is unjustly ridiculed. IMO, Homecoming is >>>>>>>>>>> SH4 The Room which was total hot garbage.

The game was not stellar but at least it was a formidable first try by a new company to delve into doing SH. If you're a fan of SH, I think you'll get your enjoyment from Homecoming...I did...

IMO, Silent Hill as a franchise is due for a complete overhaul by a team that truly UNDERSTANDS what Silent Hill is. While Resident Evil has slowly fallen from grace...the reboot from RE3 to RE4 was magnificent and perfectly melded the action gamers crave with the pacing of the original RE games. Silent Hill doesn't need to go action, but it does need a spark or re-imagination.

Advertisement

Register for free to remove this ad

Originally Posted by Luriden This is awesome news. I LOVED Homecoming. I played through it twice.

I agree. I really enjoyed Homecoming.

Originally Posted by Luriden This is awesome news. I LOVED Homecoming. I played through it twice.

Agreed haha