Originally Posted by pimpinc333 Agreed. But as my reason I stated, I doubt we will ever see this.

True but one can only hope I guess.

The CAGcast does need more JimmieMac.

Originally Posted by jrutz What the is this coup with people trying to get Wombat replaced by JimmieMac? It's been mentioned a few times in this thread already. Face it - JimmieMac was on the early podcasts, they sucked. Wombat and Cheapy have made the CAGCast the #3 gaming podcast on Digg. Jimmie had his chance. Wanna lose listeners? Then go ahead and swap Wombat and JimmieMac.

QFT. All of you who complain that Wombat is bitter and unprofessional and then posit JimmieMac as a replacement are hypocrites. I've sure JM is a perfectly nice guy, but the in the few podcasts he's appeared in, he's proven himself a surly and obnoxious, and seems more interested in making snide and flippant remarks than actually discussing topics intelligently. I, for one, would stop listening the day he took over, and I've been listening from show 1.

Originally Posted by pimpinc333 JimmieMac would be 100% better then Wombat. The majority of CAG are nerds and hate JimmieMac for the person he is. The Nerds have been picked on by a JimmieMac like chararter their whole lives either from School or even work. That's the big reason why CAG is against JimmieMac.

Hey face, shut your piehole!

There, now am I a big enough bully to be your candidate to replace Wombat? I could come to your house and smack you around a little bit if it would make you feel better.

Originally Posted by Tybee QFT. All of you who complain that Wombat is bitter and unprofessional and then posit JimmieMac as a replacement are hypocrites. I've sure JM is a perfectly nice guy, but the in the few podcasts he's appeared in, he's proven himself a surly and obnoxious, and seems more interested in making snide and flippant remarks than actually discussing topics intelligently. I, for one, would stop listening the day he took over, and I've been listening from show 1. Hey face, shut your piehole! There, now am I a big enough bully to be your candidate to replace Wombat?

Yea, your an idiot. He's doesn't say corny shit like that. You Lose.

Originally Posted by Tybee QFT. All of you who complain that Wombat is bitter and unprofessional and then posit JimmieMac as a replacement are hypocrites. I've sure JM is a perfectly nice guy, but the in the few podcasts he's appeared in, he's proven himself a surly and obnoxious, and seems more interested in making snide and flippant remarks than actually discussing topics intelligently. I, for one, would stop listening the day he took over, and I've been listening from show 1. Hey face, shut your piehole! There, now am I a big enough bully to be your candidate to replace Wombat? I could come to your house and smack you around a little bit if it would make you feel more comfortable with your choice.

Nice edit. Guarentee you hate people like JimmieMac because you've been a picked on your whole entire life by people just like him.

Wombat on the other hand is one of you guys. That's why you guys like him so much.

Originally Posted by pimpinc333 Yea, your an idiot. He's doesn't say corny shit like that. You Lose.

Yeah. I'll be crying myself to sleep tonight, champ.

Originally Posted by Tybee Yeah. I'll be crying myself to sleep tonight, champ.

Me too. I'll be sad with you.

Originally Posted by pimpinc333 Me too. I'll be sad with you.

Okay, but no spooning.

Originally Posted by Tybee Okay, but no spooning.

......You Win. I'm done responding. That one was pretty creepy.....

I can't disagree more. I can relate to Wombat, and think he brings a lot to the show. The show has always been unprofessional, whether it's about Thai whores, vagina clowns, or Knight Rider replicas.

It's ok to have a life outside of video games. There are already people out there who are paid to play and talk about it for a living. Wombat brings an everyman feel to the show.

I've been a listener for quite awhile and its a great change to hear two guys like CheapyD & Wombat doing a show that's more like hanging out with friends or down at the small vintage games store we have.

The whole show is not 100% Professional, not the rigid, mundane, review / opinion video game based garbage that's fed to its listeners. Instead the whole show is more entertaining with information that we are wanting to know..

Bottom Line.. Keep it Up fellas.. Wombat don't go anywhere..

Originally Posted by pimpinc333 Nice edit. Guarentee you hate people like JimmieMac because you've been a picked on your whole entire life by people just like him. Wombat on the other hand is one of you guys. That's why you guys like him so much.

and are you supposed to be the big jock type who picked on wombats your whole life? please. this isnt high school. ppl have different opinions on what they like and all. liking a host over another does not make you more of a nerd or more nacho over another.

Originally Posted by pimpinc333 JimmieMac would be 100% better then Wombat. The majority of CAG are nerds and hate JimmieMac for the person he is. The Nerds have been picked on by a JimmieMac like chararter their whole lives either from School or even work. That's the big reason why CAG is against JimmieMac.

Who gets picked on at work? And when did this turn into a "my dad can beat up your dad" thread?

Originally Posted by Tybee You are, of course, entitled to your opinion. You just have to be aware that when you go out of your way to attack someone with little direct provocation, you may find yourself attacked on the same grounds (or lack thereof).

I didn’t go out of my way to attack Wombat. That simply isn’t my nature. I was mealy voicing constructed criticism. I guess I was a little unfair to Wombat when I said he should be dropped or replaced. Just being less annoying sometimes would be enough for me.

Since listening to the latest Cagcast, I can’t help feeling a little guilty for starting this thread now as i didn’t think Wombat would take it to heart as much as he did. And I certainly didn’t expect Cheapy to read out my post. That must have been pretty embarrassing for him.

Like i said a few pages back, Wombat obliviously has a large following doing what he is doing and for that he has my respect.

Oh, and if i had to choose from Wombat and Jimmiemac.....put it this way, If it was called the CheapyD and Jimmiemac Cagcast, i would of stopped listening a long time ago.

Havent read a single bit of this thread .. I'm just dropping in to say that although my opinion may be less valid then others (since I've only listened to about 4 or 5 cagcasts so far) I love Wombat on the cagcast. He's the Artie Lange to Cheapy's Howard Stern. Cheapy moves the show along and can be funny himself but Wombat is the comic relief and I think you'd notice a major difference if he wasnt there.

Advertisement

Register for free to remove this ad

Originally Posted by Maklershed Havent read a single bit of this thread .. I'm just dropping in to say that although my opinion may be less valid then others (since I've only listened to about 4 or 5 cagcasts so far) I love Wombat on the cagcast. He's the Artie Lange to Cheapy's Howard Stern. Cheapy moves the show along and can be funny himself but Wombat is the comic relief and I think you'd notice a major difference if he wasnt there.

It's the internet. Everyone's opinion is valid apparently. For example, the OP should be eaten by hungry mandingos for hating on Wombat.

Originally Posted by furyk It's the internet. Everyone's opinion is valid apparently. For example, the OP should be eaten by hungry mandingos for hating on Wombat.

For the love of all thats holy!!! How many more times do i need to say it...i dont hate Wombat. He's just a little annoying at times.

I'll forever be "The Wombat Hater" in this forum now.....i'll be getting death threats on my Xboxlive account next!

I wish i'd never started this damn thread....

I am a fan of Wombat. I think he adds a great contrast to Cheapy. The two of them seem to work well with eachother. Besides, it's not like Cheapy has never been unprofessional. Remember the weeks he talked about Wombat and his masturbatory habits? (which was hilarious, by the way)

Personally I think the CAGcast is the best gaming podcast out there, and if Wombat wasn't a part of it, I don't think the show would be nearly as good. CAGcast is definitely the best fake radio show I've had the pleasure of listening to.

Originally Posted by Hex Blade I didn’t go out of my way to attack Wombat. That simply isn’t my nature. I was mealy voicing constructed criticism. I guess I was a little unfair to Wombat when I said he should be dropped or replaced. Just being less annoying sometimes would be enough for me. Since listening to the latest Cagcast, I can’t help feeling a little guilty for starting this thread now as i didn’t think Wombat would take it to heart as much as he did. And I certainly didn’t expect Cheapy to read out my post. That must have been pretty embarrassing for him. Like i said a few pages back, Wombat obliviously has a large following doing what he is doing and for that he has my respect. Oh, and if i had to choose from Wombat and Jimmiemac.....put it this way, If it was called the CheapyD and Jimmiemac Cagcast, i would of stopped listening a long time ago.

I saw your apology in the show thread. It takes courage to reconsider your actions, recognize the effect they had on other people, and apologize. I respect that. Kudos. I'm sorry as well for escalating things.

I started listening to the CAGcast shortly after Christmas last year (I got an iPod as a gift), so while I haven't been listening since the first episode, I've been tuned in for the last 15-20 or so. I'll admit that it took me a few weeks to warm up to Wombat, and there are still occasional moments when I find him a bit grating.......BUT........ I think the show would suffer greatly if he were ever removed or replaced. The easy back-and-forth banter between Wombat and Cheapy is what makes the CAGcast so enjoyable.

I listen to the CAGcast while I'm at work, and it makes the time fly by. Each week when I get to the end of the show, I always find myself saying "Wow, has it already been an hour and a half?" That tells me that they're doing something right. So I say keep up the good work, Wombat.