Originally Posted by Davestation You did not say it was horrible, only the way you spoke of it thats why referred was in quotation marks in my question. How far did you get in the series? I can understand art style being annoying but the weapons are like any other FPS game, setting is an alternate universe in the World War II era (wich World War II has been done over and over again but this is not the typical kind) and the gameplay is just like any other FPS game except it runs at 60 frames per second. Though if you have played the series enough I would like to know what game has more innovative weapons than the Chimera weapons in a FPS? In my opinion Killzone is all graphics and boring story of shooting Hellghast in the head 18 times before they die. You do have to play into Resistance to get better Chimera weapons to appreciate their value. But if you do not like it than you do not like it, Insomniac is one of the better western developers in the industry. There has not been any real game innovation in the FPS series in a long time. Hopefully Bulletstorm will live up to expectations?

I seem to recall Ship also not liking Red Dead Redemption, one of the biggest games of the year. That's why you can't go by one person's opinion. I loved Resistance, but absolutely hate puzzle games like Limbo and Braid.

Originally Posted by LimpDaddy I love you guys, but the spreadsheet and strict adherence to the categories took away from the show last week. I felt like it kept the show from flowing properly because you'd spend a minute or 2 talking about the technicalities of whether or not that should be. I'm sure that xls file is impressive, but games are 100x more interesting then the most dynamic xls.

I would like to introduce you to an Excel file I created in which you can play matching memory. I created all of the pictures in mspaint myself.

http://www.2shared.com/file/J2JoIHsy/Match.html

It is 100x more interesting than your post.

Very impressive, I'm sure Ship will like it. I just thought all the spreadsheet talk kept them from talking more about the games.

Originally Posted by LimpDaddy Very impressive, I'm sure Ship will like it. I just thought all the spreadsheet talk kept them from talking more about the games.

There were definitely issues with the talk, but I like the spreadsheet because it creates a frame of reference for what they played, which is lacking from other goty lists.

There's no avoiding discussing technicalities because of how complex games have become. He just needs to refine the spreadsheet rather than ditch it altogether. It needs to be idiot proof. Add a column for each category and just put a Y/N in there if the game qualifies or not. Then you could quickly filter on each category for games played that qualify.

Originally Posted by kingkiller33 Then Wombat totally trashes Heavy Rain calling it shit when this game received plenty of high reviews. 2011 predictation - ya'll won't even bother playing Little Big Planet 2 or Killzone 3.

So are you suggesting that Wombat put aside his impressions of a game and instead just say what others are saying? (BTW, I read a few intensely negative reviews of Heavy Rain).

Regarding your 2011 prediction - if you listed to the Cagcast regularly you'd know how wrong you are going to be.

Originally Posted by Wolfpup Windows. Even if it weren't, the very fact it's not only been announced, but a Playstation version is about to be released should keep it from that categoryt.

What *console*? Windows is not a console.

Originally Posted by Walt Jay Cheapy, Tron is in Tron Legacy. Tron is Rinzler

I watched Tron Legacy last night. I don't think CheapyD saw the same movie we did.

I agree with everything you guys say about the PS3. I have one and I want to like it but for some reason I don't. I did love Uncharted, Uncharted 2, God of War 3 and a few others but I use it mostly as my blu-ray player.

Shipwreck mentioned (on twitter) that he was going to post his 2010 spreadsheet. Did I miss that anywhere that anyone else saw? I was interested in the spreadsheet.

Originally Posted by sh10151 Shipwreck mentioned (on twitter) that he was going to post his 2010 spreadsheet. Did I miss that anywhere that anyone else saw? I was interested in the spreadsheet.

I'll try and get to it today.

Advertisement

Register for free to remove this ad

Originally Posted by shipwreck I'll try and get to it today.

Thanks!