Emailed them and got another sent over with priority shipping. Anticipating it some time this week. Kind of wished they had initially shipped it this efficiently to being with.
Made Yahtzee's #1 spot on his GOTY list, so picked one up.
Had the same experience with receiving dinged up PS3 games from Gamefly. Figured it was a small price to pay for cheap games. Though at a lost in money, I could always flip the game on Amazon trade-in once I finish it.