It's definitely the right price. I'm guessing the same thing happened there that happened in my store. I was off when the GOTY was released & the non-gamers I work with probably assumed it was the regular edition considering the cover is VERY similar with a quick glance. I noticed it...
That is quite an odd occurance. I work at a Walmart electronics in Virginia & we've never had markdowns like that. The exception being ACDC for $5. Hell we still have Madden 05s for the PS2 for $15. That's about as low as they go. Those games are all ridiculously new to have a markdown of...