After ordering the season two downloads I waited like 1 minute before ordering the free DVD. Everything worked smoothly.
Make sure you are on the right page.
http://www.telltalegames.com/store/samandmax-season2-disc
Just got a "perfect" copy of the game at Toys R Us for $19.99. There were 3 copies left but I chose only one. The guy there rang it up as $29.99 but after I told him about the ad he acknowledge his mistake. I'm pretty happy.
EDIT: Now that I've ready another threads I should've tried to...
Thank you very much OP! I ordered Wallace and Gromit and the dvds for Wallace and Gromit, Sam and Max season 1, and Tales of Monkey Island season 1 all for 2 cents + free shipping. Unlike everyone else I still got my games keys listed. :)
Anyone else who bought the games make sure your make a...