My experience with BB service is not to bad. I live in NYC and the shipping times to me feel a bit faster than Gamefly. The lower price and the fact that I play games usually a year older makes the service good for me. Give it a try.
I'm on the fence with their service. I live in NYC and the turn around time is about 2-3 days for them to receive a game and 2 days to send.
I'll probably stick with them a bit longer. Great deal though (my bro paid $50 for a similar 3 month deal).