In order to keep this list relevant and up-to-date, we need people to weigh in with their opinion on games during each voting period. Voting will take place the first fifteen days of each calendar quarter (Next: July 1-15).
I'll keep track of nominations when voting is not active. When it's time to vote, I'll change the title of the thread to reflect the voting period and list the nominations in this post. They will have the fifteen-day voting period to garner either the support necessary to be added to the list or be removed and need to be renominated again later. The support necessary will be defined as two more votes "for" than "against." For example 2-0 or 3-1, etc.
We are taking nominations for July voting!
We need input on the following games:
These have been approved and are now on the list!
I'll keep track of nominations when voting is not active. When it's time to vote, I'll change the title of the thread to reflect the voting period and list the nominations in this post. They will have the fifteen-day voting period to garner either the support necessary to be added to the list or be removed and need to be renominated again later. The support necessary will be defined as two more votes "for" than "against." For example 2-0 or 3-1, etc.
We are taking nominations for July voting!
We need input on the following games:
These have been approved and are now on the list!
January 2010
Knights in the Nightmare, nominated by botticus
Votes for: fart_bubble, Kaoz
Might & Magic: Clash of Heroes, nominated by botticus
Votes for: fart_bubble, johnnypark
October 2009
Professor Layton and the Diabolical Box, nominated by Alastor
Votes for: fart_bubble, mickeyp, Josef
Legacy of Ys, nominated by johnnypark
Votes for: fart_bubble, Josef
Phoenix Wright 2, nominated by KingBroly
Votes for: StarKnightX, botticus, mickeyp, Josef
Phoenix Wright 3, nominated by KingBroly
Votes for: StarKnightX, botticus, mickeyp, Josef
Older
GTA: Chinatown Wars, nominated by johnnypark
Votes for: bmachine, homerun17, fart_bubble, foo228, rothgar24
Retro Games Challenge, nominated by neschamp
Votes for: foltzie, fart_bubble, mickeyp, Josef
Dragon Quest V, nominated by Alastor
Votes for: cochesecochese, detectiveconan16, rothgar24, Dead of Knight, Josef
Henry Hatsworth, nominated by johnnypark
Votes for: bmachine, mickeyp
Peggle DS, nominated by bmachine
Votes for: foo228, rothgar24
Ninjatown by dembesum
Votes for: ihadFG, Cpt Hooks
Castlevania: Order of Ecclesia by johnnypark
Votes for: UltimoRey, Josef
Chrono Trigger, "nominated" by Z_meista on 11/24/2008
Votes for: johnnypark, alastor
Soul Bubbles, re-nominated by carpwrist on 11/11/2008
Vote for: mickeyp, bmachine, donssword
Final Fantasy IV, nominated by Alastor on 7/27
Votes for: ihadFG, josef
Summon Night Twin Age, nominated by rainking187 on 8/26
Votes for: botticus, gamegirl79
Luminous Arc, nominated by LeafPanda on 6/23
Votes for: Baccano, rainking187
Tony Hawk: American Sk8land, nominated by UltimoRey on 6/21
Votes for: option.iv, Mr. 420
Final Fantasy Tactics A2, nominated by StinkyCheese on 6/29
Votes for: Alastor, LeafPanda
The World Ends with You, nominated by alastor on 5/7
Votes for: option.iv, StinkyCheese, mickeyp, Rockamix
Prince of Tennis Crystal Drive, nominated by option.iv on 4/22/08
Votes for: Moxio, LeafPanda
Space Invaders Extreme, nominated by lilboo on 6/20
Votes for: Regian, 'stacheboo, rainking187
Anno 1701, nominated by fart_bubble on 3/17/08
Votes for: donssword, TheYellowDart
These were nominated but didn't garner enough support to make the list
Knights in the Nightmare, nominated by botticus
Votes for: fart_bubble, Kaoz
Might & Magic: Clash of Heroes, nominated by botticus
Votes for: fart_bubble, johnnypark
October 2009
Professor Layton and the Diabolical Box, nominated by Alastor
Votes for: fart_bubble, mickeyp, Josef
Legacy of Ys, nominated by johnnypark
Votes for: fart_bubble, Josef
Phoenix Wright 2, nominated by KingBroly
Votes for: StarKnightX, botticus, mickeyp, Josef
Phoenix Wright 3, nominated by KingBroly
Votes for: StarKnightX, botticus, mickeyp, Josef
Older
GTA: Chinatown Wars, nominated by johnnypark
Votes for: bmachine, homerun17, fart_bubble, foo228, rothgar24
Retro Games Challenge, nominated by neschamp
Votes for: foltzie, fart_bubble, mickeyp, Josef
Dragon Quest V, nominated by Alastor
Votes for: cochesecochese, detectiveconan16, rothgar24, Dead of Knight, Josef
Henry Hatsworth, nominated by johnnypark
Votes for: bmachine, mickeyp
Peggle DS, nominated by bmachine
Votes for: foo228, rothgar24
Ninjatown by dembesum
Votes for: ihadFG, Cpt Hooks
Castlevania: Order of Ecclesia by johnnypark
Votes for: UltimoRey, Josef
Chrono Trigger, "nominated" by Z_meista on 11/24/2008
Votes for: johnnypark, alastor
Soul Bubbles, re-nominated by carpwrist on 11/11/2008
Vote for: mickeyp, bmachine, donssword
Final Fantasy IV, nominated by Alastor on 7/27
Votes for: ihadFG, josef
Summon Night Twin Age, nominated by rainking187 on 8/26
Votes for: botticus, gamegirl79
Luminous Arc, nominated by LeafPanda on 6/23
Votes for: Baccano, rainking187
Tony Hawk: American Sk8land, nominated by UltimoRey on 6/21
Votes for: option.iv, Mr. 420
Final Fantasy Tactics A2, nominated by StinkyCheese on 6/29
Votes for: Alastor, LeafPanda
The World Ends with You, nominated by alastor on 5/7
Votes for: option.iv, StinkyCheese, mickeyp, Rockamix
Prince of Tennis Crystal Drive, nominated by option.iv on 4/22/08
Votes for: Moxio, LeafPanda
Space Invaders Extreme, nominated by lilboo on 6/20
Votes for: Regian, 'stacheboo, rainking187
Anno 1701, nominated by fart_bubble on 3/17/08
Votes for: donssword, TheYellowDart
These were nominated but didn't garner enough support to make the list
The following games were nominated for January 2010 voting:
Dawn Of Discovery, nominated by fart_bubble
Votes for:
Mario & Luigi: Bowser's Inside Story, nominated by botticus
Votes for: fart_bubble
Legend of Zelda: Spirit Tracks, nominated by bmachine
Votes for:
Docomodake Boing!, nominated by mickeyp
Votes for: fart_bubble
Broken Sword, nominated by mickeyp
Votes for: fart_bubble
Time Hollow, nominated by mickeyp
Votes for:
Scribblenauts, nominated by mickeyp
Votes for:
The following games were nominated for October 2009 voting:
Docomodake Boing!, nominated by mickeyp
Votes for: fart_bubble
Broken Sword, nominated by mickeyp
Votes for: fart_bubble
Time Hollow, nominated by mickeyp
Votes for: StarKnightX
Rhythm Heaven, nominated by mickeyp
Votes for:
Scribblenauts, nominated by mickeyp
Votes for: super_dawn
Super Robot Wars OG Saga: Endless Frontier, nominated by fart_bubble
Votes for:
Devil Survivor and Knights in the Nightmare, nominated by botticus
Votes for: rothgar24
Viva Pinata Pocket Paradise, nominated by donssword
Votes for:
Mario and Luigi: Bowser's Inside Story, nominated by Alastor
Votes for: Josef
The following games were nominated for July voting:
Sonic Rush Adventure, nominated by johnnypark
Votes for:
Lunar Knights, nominated by depascal22
Votes for:
Book of Ys I and II, nominated by fart_bubble
Votes for:
The following games are nominated for April voting:
These games were nominated before quarterly voting:
Dawn Of Discovery, nominated by fart_bubble
Votes for:
Mario & Luigi: Bowser's Inside Story, nominated by botticus
Votes for: fart_bubble
Legend of Zelda: Spirit Tracks, nominated by bmachine
Votes for:
Docomodake Boing!, nominated by mickeyp
Votes for: fart_bubble
Broken Sword, nominated by mickeyp
Votes for: fart_bubble
Time Hollow, nominated by mickeyp
Votes for:
Scribblenauts, nominated by mickeyp
Votes for:
The following games were nominated for October 2009 voting:
Docomodake Boing!, nominated by mickeyp
Votes for: fart_bubble
Broken Sword, nominated by mickeyp
Votes for: fart_bubble
Time Hollow, nominated by mickeyp
Votes for: StarKnightX
Rhythm Heaven, nominated by mickeyp
Votes for:
Scribblenauts, nominated by mickeyp
Votes for: super_dawn
Super Robot Wars OG Saga: Endless Frontier, nominated by fart_bubble
Votes for:
Devil Survivor and Knights in the Nightmare, nominated by botticus
Votes for: rothgar24
Viva Pinata Pocket Paradise, nominated by donssword
Votes for:
Mario and Luigi: Bowser's Inside Story, nominated by Alastor
Votes for: Josef
The following games were nominated for July voting:
Sonic Rush Adventure, nominated by johnnypark
Votes for:
Lunar Knights, nominated by depascal22
Votes for:
Book of Ys I and II, nominated by fart_bubble
Votes for:
The following games are nominated for April voting:
Big Bang Mini by dcswirl
Votes for:
Metal Slug by Filler2001
Votes for:
Peggle: Dual Shot by Foo228
Votes for:
GTA: Chinatown Wars by jeremiahkd
Votes for: dembesum
GTA: Chinatown Wars
Votes for:
Henry Hatsworth by mickyp
Votes for: bmachine
Robocalypse by mickyp
Votes for:
Votes for:
Metal Slug by Filler2001
Votes for:
Peggle: Dual Shot by Foo228
Votes for:
GTA: Chinatown Wars by jeremiahkd
Votes for: dembesum
GTA: Chinatown Wars
Votes for:
Henry Hatsworth by mickyp
Votes for: bmachine
Robocalypse by mickyp
Votes for:
Rune Factory 2, nominated by dcswirl on 12/5/2008
Votes for:
Metal Slug 7, nominated by SL4IN on 11/23/2008
Votes for:
Disgaea DS, nominated by Koggit on 11/23/2008
Votes for: SL4IN,
Dementium, re-nominated by foltzie on 11/11/2008
Votes for: SL4IN,
Lunar Knights, re-nominated by SL4IN on 11/11/2008
Votes for:
Soul Bubbles, nominated by mickeyp on 8/19
Votes for: bmachine,
Lunar Knights, nominated by Baccano on 7/18
Votes for: rainking187,
WordJong, nominated by bmachine on 7/30
Votes for: mickeyp,
Touchmaster, nominated by mickeyp on 9/9
Votes for:
Brothers in Arms DS, nominated by Rockamix on 6/29
Votes for:
Nanostray 2, nominated by option.iv on 4/22/08
Votes for: Josef
True Swing Golf, nominated by StarKnightX on 4/23/08
Votes for: Josef
Tiger Woods PGA Tour 2008, nominated by StarKnightX on 4/23/08
Votes for: slfc
Ninja Gaiden, nominated by crystalklear64 on 4/22/08
Votes for: mickeyp, Josef
Flash Focus, nominated by KSHLove on 2/13/08
Votes for:
Final Fantasy XII Revenant Wings, nominated by sleepkyng on 2/22/08
Votes for:
Professor Layton and the Curious Village, nominated by Josef on 2/23/08
Votes for: keithp
Phoenix Wright 2+3, nominated by mickeyp on 2/24/08
Votes for:
Votes for:
Metal Slug 7, nominated by SL4IN on 11/23/2008
Votes for:
Disgaea DS, nominated by Koggit on 11/23/2008
Votes for: SL4IN,
Dementium, re-nominated by foltzie on 11/11/2008
Votes for: SL4IN,
Lunar Knights, re-nominated by SL4IN on 11/11/2008
Votes for:
Soul Bubbles, nominated by mickeyp on 8/19
Votes for: bmachine,
Lunar Knights, nominated by Baccano on 7/18
Votes for: rainking187,
WordJong, nominated by bmachine on 7/30
Votes for: mickeyp,
Touchmaster, nominated by mickeyp on 9/9
Votes for:
Brothers in Arms DS, nominated by Rockamix on 6/29
Votes for:
Nanostray 2, nominated by option.iv on 4/22/08
Votes for: Josef
True Swing Golf, nominated by StarKnightX on 4/23/08
Votes for: Josef
Tiger Woods PGA Tour 2008, nominated by StarKnightX on 4/23/08
Votes for: slfc
Ninja Gaiden, nominated by crystalklear64 on 4/22/08
Votes for: mickeyp, Josef
Flash Focus, nominated by KSHLove on 2/13/08
Votes for:
Final Fantasy XII Revenant Wings, nominated by sleepkyng on 2/22/08
Votes for:
Professor Layton and the Curious Village, nominated by Josef on 2/23/08
Votes for: keithp
Phoenix Wright 2+3, nominated by mickeyp on 2/24/08
Votes for:
Last edited by a moderator: