I tried talking my way out of it but it wasnt even worth it. The manager said the game was worth onthing to them since it was ringing up as $0 and if I wanted to return it, I would get nothing back for it as the deal was over. You are right in that it doesnt make much sense since it is basically exhanging a $60 game for another $60 game, but her reasoning was that the values were not equal in the system and she wouldnt approve it.
See that annoys me to no end. Not that you couldn't fight them, but that they even put you in that situation. Makes me wanna go mess with them just out of spite, heh. It's like you said, for them to say that game is worthless to them is stupid cause I know if someone left a worthless game on their counter they'd be selling it for sixty quick. We'll see when I go argue with them Wednesday I guess.