Question about rasslin' games on the GCN

Hi guys. I've read a lot of reviews to try to find my answer but nothing really clarified anything for me. Here's my situation: I'm looking at buying either WrestleMania XIX or Day of Reckoning. My question is, which will allow me to best use the create a wrestler feature to create classic guys from the 80's as well as nWo guys from the late 90's? I've seen some really bizarre CAWs like Batman and Superman, but I wanna know if I can create me some Macho Man, ya know? Thanks for any insight.