Well, I ordered a few from this sale and in the past few months. Im probably hovering around 30 games bought used lifetime from gamefly. Ive gotten every single one within 3 days (live in Cincy), the cases and manuals are always perfect, and the disc have at worst be slightly used ranging to like new condition. Perhaps Ive just been dodging bullets, but until I get burnt once or twice, gamefly is awesome and will be the only retailer I go through for used discs.
Hey good for you, I ordered one game this time, never got it. They refunded me but Still. I wanted TWG 11 for 17.99$ :(