Defensive much? If you actually read his post instead of getting so enraged over one line you might have noticed that he was talking about how weak the limited edition seems to be, not about the actual game quality.
This. I'm still very excited for Halo 4, I'm just less then impressed by the contents of the limited edition. They're asking $40 more and offering very little.
One of the big detractors for me is also finding out that the Forward Unto Dawn is only a digital copy. I'd rather spend the extra few bucks and get it on blu-ray. I'll probably just hold my LE preorder until the midnight launch though, and downgrade at the counter.