Did anyone try to PM Newegg's price on Halo 4 for this deal? I know target has it for $39.99 but Newegg has it for $5 less (with promo code).
That would probably be a long shot, as every rep I dealt with actually verified the price and availability on Amazon before they price matched the item. Unfortunately it says that the item is currently out of stock on Newegg, not to mention the actual gaming page still displays it as $59.99. Most reps will only go as far as opening up newegg and searching for the actual game, it is very YMMV whether or not the rep actually goes through the trouble of finding the ad and then accepting the $34.99 promo code price. But as I said the bigger problem is the fact that the item is out of stock, since they have to verify that the website actually has the item in stock. I got lucky with Assassins Creed 3 as when I PMed it, it stated "back in stock on December 16th", but the rep was nice enough to list it as in stock and price match it for me.
I guess at this point the only way of really knowing is by calling them and seeing what they can do for you, just don't get your hopes up too much. My recommendation is that you find the holiday ad on the newegg website and walk the rep through on how to quickly find it.