Tempted for Blackgate, but from what was uncovered the other day, there may be an HD port to consoles in the near future.
Blackgate is pretty fun. Just for reference, I really enjoyed Arkham Origins on console, so I'm not a hater. I'm still trying to get a feel if I like it or not, got it for $25 over the holidays. It has that feel of where they tried and succeeded at doing something unique and fun, but there are several places where they obviously tried to mimic the console version and it failed. I think it would have been better had they been given more leeway to stray from console, rather than trying to emulate it.
Take, for example, an early boss fight where you shoot the explosive gel to turn on switches (and can do so over and over without damage). Many of the devices could be called "widget to allow progress #4". It is less of a logical use of an item, than simply the designers trying to cram devices in the console version into the game that really don't make sense in that context.
The graphic style of the cutscenes is great and the fighting is a downgraded but still fun version of the console.