Vintage Variety- Sonic Ultimate Genesis Collection Reviewed

DesertEagleXIX

CAGiversary!
Feedback
3 (100%)
As gamers witnessed the proliferation of retro titles on the Virtual Console and Xbox Live, many (including us) worried that the end of compilation disks was near. When publishers began offering single games for a five to eight dollar investment, cramming a multitude of tiles into a budget-priced disk no longer seemed economically prudent. Fortunately, this piece-meal approach to classic gaming hasn’t been fully realized, as a large number of consoles haven’t made the jump online. Thank you, casual gamers for preserving the retro anthology.

As the latest example of a compilation disk, the Sonic Ultimate Genesis Collection doesn’t disappoint in both diversity and value. A great majority of the collection’s titles are available on the Virtual Console- for eight dollars a pop. Gamers thinking about buying a title or three from Nintendo’s store would find a much better value with this assemblage. Additionally, unlike the single game approach, the collection brings the games together via a unified system, which loosely recreates the feeling of playing a system.

When players first insert the disk, they are treated to a front-end inspired by the design aesthetics of the original Genesis hardware. Players can sort from the available titles by alphabetically, by release date, or by a customizable user rating; be enjoyed this iTunes-like flexibility. Once a game is chosen, the player is shown a control screen, and the game is instantly playable. The entire collection appears to be stored in internal memory, as there is a noticeable lack of any load times. Additionally, players can unlock additional arcade games and designer interviews, as well as view box and cartridge art.

Continued here: http://tech-gaming.com/2009/02/12/vintage-variety-sonic-ultimate-genesis-collection-reviewed.aspx
 
I don't know if you've noticed, but there's been a debate raging on CAG whether or not it's a bad thing Sonic 3 and Knuckles isn't included. I feel it's a tremendous screw up on an otherwise nearly perfect compilation. If the "lock on" features were included, would your review be an A or A+?
 
I wish this was available on the PS2 and PSP as Sega Genesis Collection 2, but I really doubt it will happen.

I really like the idea that Sega is porting their classics, hoping to see more collections in the future! :)
 
[quote name='Friend of Sonic']I don't know if you've noticed, but there's been a debate raging on CAG whether or not it's a bad thing Sonic 3 and Knuckles isn't included. I feel it's a tremendous screw up on an otherwise nearly perfect compilation. If the "lock on" features were included, would your review be an A or A+?[/QUOTE]

You mean Sonic 3+Sonic and Knuckles Locked on, right?

It's a minor issue, and wouldn't have changed our score. We marked it down for not including some of the more niche titles that haven't been available previously, like Subterrainia.
 
[quote name='DesertEagleXIX']You mean Sonic 3+Sonic and Knuckles Locked on, right?

It's a minor issue, and wouldn't have changed our score. We marked it down for not including some of the more niche titles that haven't been available previously, like Subterrainia.[/QUOTE]
Yep-- just curious. It's true, there could have been some more titles included that licensing issues wouldn't have prevented.
 
So which one is the version to get? PS3 or 360? Or are they pretty much identical. If so I would probably give the nod to the PS3 version for the better d-pad.
 
[quote name='willardhaven']A Sonic compilation missing the best Sonic game is a minor issue?

It was on PS2...[/QUOTE]

Let me clarify. Sonic 1,2, and 3, Spinball,3D Blast and Sonic and Knuckles are all on the compilation.

What is missing, is the ability to lock-on Sonic and Knuckles to Sonic 2 and 3. While I understand some are bothered, as this was in the previous compilation, we feel it's relativity minor.
 
bread's done
Back
Top