Jump to content


- - - - -

Fallout 3--which system?


#1 Jesse_Dylan   CAGiversary! CAGiversary!   3402 Posts   Joined 7.4 Years Ago  

Jesse_Dylan

Posted 01 September 2008 - 12:46 PM

For those of you planning to buy Fallout 3 immediately (I certainly am), which system are you purchasing it for?

I've posted this in the PC forum, so obviously I'm thinking PC, and hey, I had to put it somewhere. I actually bought a 360 in 2006 to play Oblivion. It went well, though I had some disc-read errors. However, these days, I have a decent PC, which I upgraded the hell out of over time. But since they're not releasing system requirements for Fallout 3 (still!), how am I to know?

My PC has an AMD dual-core processor running at 2.5 Ghz or so (per core), 4gb of RAM (why do I capitalize RAM but not gb?), and an Nvidia 8800 GT video card. I forget what variety the card is, but it's stock overclocked. I did a lot of research, and it's one of the best of the 8800s.

So you'd think my PC would run it better than my 360, but who the hell even knows?

Maybe if I were smart, I wouldn't buy it right away; I'd get demos on 360 and PC both and see how they run, how stable the different versions are, and I'd listen to comparisons from the gaming media and users.

Something else to consider is whether there will be user-created content. For Oblivion, there was a ton of stuff. I actually bought a copy of Oblivion for my PC as well and spent extreme amounts of time earlier this summer downloading a bunch of stuff and getting it all working together. (But have I actually played it? No. Lame.) I would have felt left-out, missing all that by just playing on 360, but I still had the core experience there, and it was fantastic and obsessing.

Except for the disc-read errors... (But the fall dashboard update, which will allow "installation" of games to a hard disc, solves that for the most part... and creates HDD space issues since I only have a 20gb drive.)

Another consideration might be that I play Xbox in a comfy chair. My PC chair is not comfy, and I already spend too much time sitting here. There is also the issue of interface device. Oblivion was great (probably best) with a mouse/keyboard, but it was fine on the control pad as well. I wonder how Fallout 3 will behave in that sense?

Sorry, that was long, but that's the dilemma. I already have the PC version pre-ordered for $49.99. There's another plus for the PC--it's $10 cheaper! I don't care about all the extras and junk.

#2 darthbudge   The Real DB CAGiversary!   20046 Posts   Joined 8.9 Years Ago  

Posted 01 September 2008 - 01:07 PM

Well, we really don't know what Fallout 3 is gonna require of your PC. However, I am pretty sure your PC would be able to play it on High Settings.

Now personally, I would get it on PC. PC is $10 cheaper, you get mods and you are more likely to continue receiving patches for it over time. Also, historically, most DLC as been free for the PC counterparts of console games. So that is an added bonus.

I also like sitting in my PC chair more then I do on my couch, but that is probably just me. However, I haven't upgraded my PC in awhile, so I am gonna get the game on 360.

However, with the 360, you do get to play on your HDTV if you have one, and you know that it will always run smoothly. Finally, on the 360 you get Achievements, which I personally like alot.


#3 Jesse_Dylan   CAGiversary! CAGiversary!   3402 Posts   Joined 7.4 Years Ago  

Jesse_Dylan

Posted 01 September 2008 - 01:22 PM

My HDTV is pretty small. :) So that's not too much of an issue, I guess. You're right that achievements are fun, even though I really don't care about gamer score.

Darn it. This is a tough decision. I guess I can always pick up the 360 version in a year or two if I go PC.

#4 ighosty   I just lost the game. CAGiversary!   1644 Posts   Joined 8.0 Years Ago  

Posted 01 September 2008 - 01:27 PM

I'm getting the 360 version, because of the exclusive DLC, don't remember if they said the PC was getting that or not.
Posted Image
Currently Playing:
:360: SKATE 2
:ps3: Killzone 2
:ps2: Rogue Galaxy

#5 52club   This ain't intramurals!!! CAGiversary!   684 Posts   Joined 7.7 Years Ago  

Posted 01 September 2008 - 01:36 PM

I'm getting the 360 version, because of the exclusive DLC, don't remember if they said the PC was getting that or not.


Exclusive 360 download content=free on the PC in six months

I haven't been a computer gamer since around 2001, but since I've built a new computer I'll have to say the experience is superior for some games. I would never play NHL 08 or Burnout on a PC, but a game like Fallout was made for the PC. I would be shocked if the PC game isn't the superior version, even if the marketing suggests the console version is great.

I know I'm going to need to upgrade my system to get the full performance, even though I just built it. I'm hoping to score some BF deals. Maybe you could find a BF deal to upgrade your computer chair.
Space for Rent:lol:

#6 eswat   Kill many bear CAGiversary!   2344 Posts   Joined 7.9 Years Ago  

Posted 01 September 2008 - 01:54 PM

PC.

360 may have the exclusive DLC, but if the mod tools are coming, then I'd rather get good mods from the fanbase than Dog Armour from Bethesda.

#7 Jesse_Dylan   CAGiversary! CAGiversary!   3402 Posts   Joined 7.4 Years Ago  

Jesse_Dylan

Posted 01 September 2008 - 02:03 PM

...a game like Fallout was made for the PC. I would be shocked if the PC game isn't the superior version...


Actually, if Oblivion is any indication, Xbox 360 is the lead platform. That doesn't mean it's better on 360 necessarily, as a good PC, or possibly even a PS3, can enhance something that's been originally programmed for a 360.

We ran into some problems with Oblivion, though; it really should have run better on the PC with good hardware, but it was held back by its 360 roots.

Again, that doesn't mean it's not better on PC necessarily. It just means it's not all it could have been.

#8 Chacrana   You wa Cock CAGiversary!   22669 Posts   Joined 11.2 Years Ago  

Posted 01 September 2008 - 04:02 PM

PC.

360 may have the exclusive DLC, but if the mod tools are coming, then I'd rather get good mods from the fanbase than Dog Armour from Bethesda.


Wasn't MS' plan to have the exclusive DLC on the PC, as well?

it was probably in there because I'm a flaming homosexual.


#9 keithp   CAGiversary! CAGiversary!   5561 Posts   Joined 11.3 Years Ago  

Posted 01 September 2008 - 04:26 PM

Actually, if Oblivion is any indication, Xbox 360 is the lead platform. That doesn't mean it's better on 360 necessarily, as a good PC, or possibly even a PS3, can enhance something that's been originally programmed for a 360.

We ran into some problems with Oblivion, though; it really should have run better on the PC with good hardware, but it was held back by its 360 roots.

Again, that doesn't mean it's not better on PC necessarily. It just means it's not all it could have been.


Exhibit 2: Mass Effect. This game could've been so great on PC, but clearly the focus was 360 with PC as an afterthought despite what the developers promised.

Anyway, I'd say the mods alone are worth getting Fallout 3 on PC rather than XBox. Although if you really want to, pick up one and play through it and then pick up the other down the road after the price drops hit.

#10 Jesse_Dylan   CAGiversary! CAGiversary!   3402 Posts   Joined 7.4 Years Ago  

Jesse_Dylan

Posted 01 September 2008 - 04:47 PM

Although if you really want to, pick up one and play through it and then pick up the other down the road after the price drops hit.


That's what I did with Oblivion... Got it on 360 (although out of necessity) and recently picked it up on PC. But if I had it to do over again, maybe I'd just play it on PC in the first place. I'll have to see if the fall dashboard update and game installation features work well before going with the 360 version, I think. I don't know why this is such an agonizing decision for me. (I've got nice surround sound on my 360 as well, thanks to a CAG deal.)

I'll probably just stick with the PC version. There are just so many factors. Like which market do I want to support most?

But if I was going to play both versions, I'd probably want to start with 360. It might be hard to go back to after being spoiled by the PC version.

Wasn't MS' plan to have the exclusive DLC on the PC, as well?


I believe so. They're happy either way, I think. I suppose they get a bigger cut of the profits on the 360 version (thus the $10 hike on the console versions), but they kind of run the PC scene, too, with Windows. And all that "Games for Windows" marketing nonsense.

#11 Dante Devil   Uh... CAGiversary!   1650 Posts   Joined 11.4 Years Ago  

Dante Devil

Posted 01 September 2008 - 04:53 PM

Was going to buy it for the 360, but since my 360 died, going with the PS3.

dantedevil0ec6zs.jpgcagerssmall6vi5lm.gif

ach.png

 


#12 zenzen   CAG Veteran CAG Veteran   6 Posts   Joined 7.0 Years Ago  

Posted 01 September 2008 - 05:03 PM

I'm getting it for PS3. Day one!

Only MS exclusive game I'll get it for 360. I'm tired of RROD.

#13 thespamofpower   No idea what's going on CAGiversary!   543 Posts   Joined 11.2 Years Ago  

thespamofpower

Posted 01 September 2008 - 10:40 PM

When I get it, it'll be on the PC. I gotta justify this thing somehow. ;)

#14 zionoverfire   C10Cl12 CAGiversary!   18241 Posts   Joined 10.9 Years Ago  

zionoverfire

Posted 06 September 2008 - 05:32 AM

I'm running a comparible system to yours and I'm planning on picking up the PC version. It's going to be $10 cheaper or more, it's reasonably easy to find good PC deals within a couple months of launch, all the "exclusive" DLC for the 360 will eventually come out on the PC for free and you'll have access to all those wonderful fan mods which can be a total blast.

However on the negative side it will likely come with more bugs, both Oblivion and Morrowind had a number of annoying bugs in with the PC launch version that took a bit of time to get patched.

#15 whoknows   Time and Eternity for all of time and eternity CAGiversary!   35107 Posts   Joined 10.7 Years Ago   Has been playing Time and Eternity
PS3

Posted 06 September 2008 - 05:39 AM

After deliberating long and hard I've decided to go with the Gamecube version.


Short load times FTW!

#16 sendme   CAGiversary! CAGiversary!   5067 Posts   Joined 11.3 Years Ago  

Posted 07 September 2008 - 08:42 AM

If I get it I'm getting it for the PC. Shooters for me are always on the PC unless it does not come out on the PC or it comes out on the 360 or PS3 long befor it comes to the PC, like with the Halo games. However if they use punkbuster for their online multiplayer then chances are when the price drops I will be forced to get it for the 360.
Posted Image

#17 Maklershed   Feed me a stray cat CAGiversary!   34086 Posts   Joined 9.8 Years Ago  

Posted 07 September 2008 - 01:45 PM

I'm personally getting it on the 360 for the exclusive DLC and achievements.

Posted Image

#18 Richard Longfellow   Mr. Warmth CAGiversary!   1396 Posts   Joined 8.4 Years Ago  

Richard Longfellow

Posted 07 September 2008 - 02:51 PM

...We ran into some problems with Oblivion, though; it really should have run better on the PC with good hardware, but it was held back by its 360 roots...


I think the main problem is that Bethesda can't make an efficient open-world game engine. Morrowind was a dog, too, even though it looked nice in its day it was horribly clunky drawing in the environment.

#19 Sideswiper   CAGiversary! CAGiversary!   445 Posts   Joined 8.2 Years Ago  

Sideswiper

Posted 07 September 2008 - 06:24 PM

PC version will probably get user made mods, which I usually enjoy more than the original game.
Posted Image

#20 Bullbert   CAG Veteran CAG Veteran   27 Posts   Joined 8.0 Years Ago  

Bullbert

Posted 27 September 2008 - 07:33 AM

After deliberating long and hard I've decided to go with the Gamecube version.

Short load times FTW!

Get the PS2 version from 7-11. (reference to clueless 7-11 ad campaign just released this week) 8-)

edit: Oh, and I will be getting the PC version, probably waiting until late November. I have one Gamestop $25 giftcard, with a second GS $25 gc arriving around that time. "Free" game around the same time as the second round of patches. Kind of hard to beat that.

#21 Kaijufan   CAGiversary! CAGiversary!   9848 Posts   Joined 11.4 Years Ago  

Posted 28 September 2008 - 12:58 AM

After all the cool mods Oblivion got I'll never be buying the console version of a Bethesda game again. I've been waiting for a decent deal on the PC version of Oblivion GotY for a long time now.
Posted Image

#22 udabenshen   Almost Revolutionary... CAGiversary!   145 Posts   Joined 7.6 Years Ago  

Posted 28 September 2008 - 05:46 AM

Seriously, go with pc. you have a good enough graphics card and processor. It was announced at the microsoft press conference at E3, the same place they announced the dlc for 360, that it was "xbox 360 and games for windows exclusive." It also is a games for windows game, so if you REALLY want to play it with a controller you can just plug it in and it will work. I have a similar machine that can run oblivion great so I don't see fallout 3 being a major problem for an 8800. And buy the game, please.

#23 jlarlee   Tom Brady GOAT CAGiversary!   5562 Posts   Joined 11.4 Years Ago  

Posted 28 September 2008 - 06:31 AM

That is a tough decision. Kind of glad my pc is a dog which forces my hand in getting the 360 version.
Posted Image

#24 Kyo   a.k.a. Phoom CAGiversary!   344 Posts   Joined 10.6 Years Ago  

Posted 28 September 2008 - 06:40 AM

Anyone read anything bout copy protection on the PC version? While I'm a PC gamer at heart, these copy protection are getting ridiculous ...

This is probably determine which version is superior ... if the PC protection is crappy, I'll end up buying a ps3 version.

#25 Chacrana   You wa Cock CAGiversary!   22669 Posts   Joined 11.2 Years Ago  

Posted 28 September 2008 - 02:46 PM

I don't think anything's been said in regards to that, but it's published by Bethesda, and they were hella lenient with Oblivion. There wasn't even a CD key - just put the disc in and you can play it. Now wasn't that nice?

it was probably in there because I'm a flaming homosexual.


#26 mogamer   CAGiversary! CAGiversary!   1269 Posts   Joined 8.3 Years Ago  

Posted 28 September 2008 - 04:29 PM

I don't think anything's been said in regards to that, but it's published by Bethesda, and they were hella lenient with Oblivion. There wasn't even a CD key - just put the disc in and you can play it. Now wasn't that nice?

You make a good point. But the way publishers have been adding fucking protection schemes lately, you can't take anything for granted. I'll wait and see what, if anything, Bethesda is using. If they're using any form of Securom, then it's the Xbox 360 version for me.

#27 HyeVltg3   Needs Mo Gameshare CAGiversary!   958 Posts   Joined 6.6 Years Ago  

Posted 02 October 2008 - 05:19 AM

Dude get it for whatever you use more of and show off with. PC/360.

I got it (pre-ordered) for my ps3 because I can bring it(my ps3) to my friends house and showoff the game....but I can't bring over my PC...I got it because I hate playing non-online games alone, better to show your friends, how you beheaded that guy, then to be in your room...alone going, "BOOYA, DID YOU SEE THAT!"..and no one's there to high-five you..lol

#28 paintball745   PHD in deals CAGiversary!   516 Posts   Joined 7.6 Years Ago  

paintball745

Posted 02 October 2008 - 05:36 PM

i would get it on the pc because it was just announced that the pc version will have little to no drm just like a disk check.

source: http://www.aeropause...n-pc-minus-drm/

#29 deliveryboy15   CAGiversary! CAGiversary!   51 Posts   Joined 7.7 Years Ago  

deliveryboy15

Posted 03 October 2008 - 12:45 PM

Here is a good interview with some important questions addressed.

Highlights:
no DRM
not "console-ified"
DLC for 360 same day for PC

I've been having the same debate as you about whether or not to pick it up for the 360 or PC, but after reading this interview and the savings of $10. I've decided to get the PC version.

#30 Chacrana   You wa Cock CAGiversary!   22669 Posts   Joined 11.2 Years Ago  

Posted 03 October 2008 - 02:09 PM

Well, there we go. So Fallout 3 is cheaper on the PC, and obviously better.

it was probably in there because I'm a flaming homosexual.