I haven't listened the whole time, but my first CAGcast was Calling All CAGs, sometime in Fall 2007.
I remember why Wombat says "bread's done" at the end of each episode... and why 'kazoo' is the safe word.
I remember CheapyD shitting his pants at a Japanese office.
My favorite CAGcast was...
It's similar, the blue bar is Focus Points, used for spells and weapon arts. It may be replenished from Ash flask, and you may choose how to allot your total estus between health and focus.
Yeah, bought Pikman 3, DKC Tropical Freeze, and Super Mario 3D World. Also bought Super Mario Galaxy 2, but then I found the original for $18.99 at GameStop, so I returned the Nintendo Selects version.