I'm seriously never going to play the game again. After sitting on my shelf, collecting dust for like two years, I just finished the game last week. It's not a knock on the game by any means, it's an awesome game, but I have so many to play on my backlog.
I just came back from GS ten mins ago. Luckily they had a new SEALED copy of Batman: AC GOTY, but YMMV. I've shopped at GS before where they gave me an unsealed display box and just put CDs on there I also traded in Batman AA for Xbox 360 and was disappointed that it's only 2 dollars. At least...
Free shipping, went down from $37 :)
http://www.amazon.com/Dead-Redemption-Game-microsoft-xbox-360/dp/B005N4HBE6/ref=sr_1_1?ie=UTF8&qid=1335833927&sr=8-1