To everyone who didn't get the offer, forget Gamestop. Find the coupon scan someone posted early on (sorry, I don't remember which page) and price match at Best Buy. Tried at two different locations, got the deal on multiple games, and they even let me keep the coupon after.
I emailed Gamestop about this deal. Here's the vague, unhelpful reply I got today. Thanks, Gamestop...
Dear Customer,
Thank you for contacting PowerUpRewards.com.
“Unfortunately this was an offer that was not available for all customers. It was made available to a selection of customers...
Anyone want to try setting order to this chaos? Let's try to figure out why some people are getting it to work and some people aren't. So far we've figured out that:
1. It doesn't seem to discriminate between the free Powerup Accounts and the paid ones.
2. The SONY50 code is only working about...