I don't know about the new video games, but I do know that the store, Finders, is a real store in my town and has been around for at least the 3 years I've lived here.
So it doesn't seem as likely that they are out to scam anyone.
Anyone have Wait Til Your Father Gets Home and want to trade?
I have:
Animaniacs Volume 1 or 2
Pinky and the Brain Volume 1 or 2
Send me a PM if you are interested.