[quote name='breakfuss']Ok, so I take it gutted = unsealed, and not necessarily inserts/pamphlets removed?[/QUOTE]
Ya. They open a copy of the game, put the case on display, and have the disc behind the counter. Sometimes they remove the booklet/inserts and put them in the envelope with the disc. Often, they leave the booklet/inserts in the case on display (in which case there's a small chance somebody might snag something or steal a code from inside the case, but, in my experience, I don't think I've ever run into that issue).
So, ya, long story short...a gutted copy SHOULD come with all inserts.