A Misleading Headline Meant to Cast a Pall of Shame

PittsburghAfterDark

CAGiversary!
Boehner Rents Apartment Owned by Lobbyist in D.C.
By Thomas B. Edsall and Jonathan Weisman
Washington Post Staff Writers
Wednesday, February 8, 2006; A03

Rep. John A. Boehner (R-Ohio), who was elected House majority leader last week, is renting his Capitol Hill apartment from a veteran lobbyist whose clients have direct stakes in legislation Boehner has co-written and that he has overseen as chairman of the Education and the Workforce Committee.

The relationship between Boehner, John D. Milne and Milne's wife, Debra R. Anderson, underscores how intertwined senior lawmakers have become with the lobbyists paid to influence legislation. Boehner's primary residence is in West Chester, Ohio, but for $1,600 a month, he rents a two-bedroom basement apartment near the House office buildings on Capitol Hill owned by Milne, Boehner spokesman Don Seymour said yesterday. Boehner's monthly rent appears to be similar to other rentals of two-bedroom English basement apartments close to the House side of the Capitol in Southeast, based on a review of apartment listings.

Milne's clients -- including restaurant chains and health insurance companies -- hired him to lobby on issues at the heart of Boehner's work, including minimum-wage increases, small-business tax breaks and tax-free savings accounts to help cover insurance costs, congressional lobbying records show.

In the weeks preceding last week's GOP leadership elections, Boehner acknowledged his close ties to the lobbying community, but he assured Republican lawmakers that all of his relationships were ethical and he campaigned on a platform of change and reform. Seymour reiterated that message last night.

"John Milne does not lobby John Boehner on any issue and has not lobbied him on any issue during the time period in which John has been renting the property," he said.

Seymour added that he does not know if other members of Milne's mCapitol Management firm have lobbied Boehner. "We really have no idea on this one," he said. "We'd have to know who else works for those firms, which we don't offhand. It's possible the answer is yes, but we don't know."

House members may not accept anything from lobbyists worth more than $50. If Boehner is paying market-rate rent, it would appear he is not violating that rule.

Boehner's work closely coincides with the interests of Milne. In 2002, the House approved the Economic Security and Worker Assistance Act, a tax measure originally drafted by Boehner, Rep. Sam Johnson (R-Tex.) and Rep. Howard P. "Buck" McKeon (R-Calif.) as the Back to Work Act. The measure eventually was signed into law.

Lobbying disclosure forms indicate that one of Milne's clients, Fortis Health Plans, hired him to lobby the Economic Security and Worker Assistance Act.

Another client, the Buca di Beppo chain of Italian restaurants, hired Milne to push the Small Business Tax Fairness Act, which would allow restaurants to deduct the cost of investments at a faster pace. The measure was introduced by Rep. Kay Granger (R-Tex.) in 2003, with Boehner as one of 15 co-sponsors. Many of its provisions have since become law.

Fortis, now called Assurant Health, also asked Milne to push Health Savings Accounts, the tax-free savings accounts established by Congress to help with health care costs not covered by high-deductible plans. Boehner is a proponent of such accounts, which President Bush is targeting for a major expansion.

Buca di Beppo and another restaurant chain, Parasole Restaurant Holdings Inc., also hired Milne to lobby on the minimum wage and tax credits for tips, issues directly under the Education and the Workforce Committee's purview.

The restaurant industry has long fought minimum-wage increases, seeking instead to augment restaurant wages with tips that become more valuable if they can avoid taxation. Despite numerous attempts by Democrats and some pro-labor Republicans, the minimum wage has not been raised since 1997, when it was lifted from $4.75 to $5.15. Since then, inflation has eroded its value to near-record lows.

That such companies would hire Milne is no mystery. His firm overtly promotes its connections to influential lawmakers.

"At mCapitol Management, we specialize in leveraging relationships on our clients' behalf. Our bipartisan team's unique resources allow our clients unparalleled access at the international, federal, state and local level," the firm's Web site boasts.

Milne could not be reached by phone or e-mail. His wife, Anderson, who is on the advisory board of mCapitol, said she and her husband have been friends with Boehner and his wife for years. After buying the house in 2004, she said, she mentioned at a social gathering that they had a place to rent, and Boehner said he was interested.

Anderson described Boehner as an "excellent tenant" who pays his rent on time.

Seymour said Boehner originally met Anderson in the early 1990s, when she worked in the administration of President George H.W. Bush.

Washington Post

Wait, WTF is this story really about if not the misleading headline?

A congressman rents an apartment from someone that does lobbying. Okay, well, must be improper right?

Then the article goes on to state that the $1,600 a month in rent is consistent with rates advertised in real estate and rental guides.

So what's the story?

Is this not similar to a "So when did you stop beating your wife?" question or statement?

Where's the story about anyone else in congress and their living arrangements? Why don't we investigate the other 534 members of congress and see if anyone is getting below market rents, mortgages or purchase prices on owned property?

Yes, I would bitch about this as unfair reporting if done to any member of congress. Misleading headline, facts don't support inflamatory rhetoric meant to draw readership, typical MSM sensationalism of a non-story.

Okay so Nancy Pelosi has an apartment in Georgetown (I'm just making this up I don't know.) that is owned by a major supporter of People For the American Way but pays full market value in rent. Big f'in deal. Chuck Schumer purchased a brownstone walk up from the head of NARAL (Again, just trying to make a point, not saying it's true.) and paid the going market rate on it. Big f'in deal.

I fail to see how this is news.
 
Unless he's paying the rent with money that he's getting from the lobbyist then it doesn't matter. They're just making a story to get attention, I guess it worked :p.
 
it could be trying to link why he feels that people in congress should still be able to accept money and trips from lobbyists (he just wants people to show what all they have taken)

with that said, yes it is a misleading headline
 
I agree it is a nothing story but how is the title misleading?

It appears Boehner is renting a D.C. apartment owned by a lobbyist.

FYI- Pitty- someone that does lobbying is a lobbyist.
 
It does, though, create the appearance of impropriety, even if there is nothing technically improper about it. In this age of increased scrutiny of lobbyists and their activities, I would think the new Republican leader would want to be extra careful.

BTW, the refs robbed the Seahawks -- the only reason you have the 5-time Steeler champions banner.
 
[quote name='PittsburghAfterDark']Wait, WTF is this story really about if not the misleading headline?[/QUOTE]

It's about a reporter at the Post being told to write a story concerning Boehner and lobbyists and grasping at straws to try and make that connection. Or it's a malicious smear attempt with no evidence of impropriety, whatever you like.
 
bread's done
Back
Top