I just bought my wife that Fishing game last night at Gamestop. She loves those damn Fishing games.
I only bought it there because I had 20% off a new game, and a ton of credit. Oh well, just ordered one from Best Buy to return to GS.
Hopefully I won't have any problem. The copy I got last night was the last one, so it was one of those Gamestop Specials. But I'm guessing that shouldn't matter right? They consider it new, and they probably won't remember they sold me one of the open ones when I return a sealed copy.
....unless I get the same guy. I did kind of make a big deal about getting an open one.