So I contacted Gamestop about my game. Told them that the condition was unacceptable, and that I wanted a sealed copy for the money I was paying.
The answer back was "Sounds like you have a defective item. Please let us know exactly what the items was, and if you want a refund or replacement". Told them I wanted the replacement. A week went by, and no more information on it. Messaged them, and a couple days later I get another email saying that they recently shipped my replacement out.
So what arrived? Another unwrapped copy. This time with a clearance sticker on it, and that clear sticker on the top, bottom and side of the case. Looking at the clearance sticker, they printed it out the day before telling me a replacement was being shipped. On top of that, the game is rattling around inside the case.
They never asked me to send back the first copy. Makes me seriously tempted to return it for a refund.