[quote name='MrNinjaSquirrel']Red Dead, it was mostly just the long long travel times, or the long loading times trying to fast travel. I didn't care for the really small reticle either. I think I might have liked it better on 360, as the PS3 version had a ton of frame rate issues, and ran at a lower resolution.
La Noire, was just boring. Wander around, wait for controller to rumble, ask questions with the replies that were nothing like what I wanted (doubt is just you shouting at them, which didn't feel at all right to me). I really didn't care for Phelps, as he and everyone around him was just sort of a jerk the whole time. And the ending was much to rushed, which was saying a lot considering how long it was. It was a great mission, and then
. I was just really bored and let down, and I know I'm not the only one. Seems like a game for a very particular set of gamers, and I wasn't it.[/QUOTE]
I thought Red Dead was a well thought out game with a great amount of detail compared to other open world titles. The graphics, game play, story and setting were amazing. I played on the 360 and didn't have much trouble with load times at all. I was impressed at how well R* was able to pull it off. The vast amount of land in the game reminded me of GTA San Andreas. The online multi play was solid as well.
As for LA Noire, I agree. The story had some up moments but the ending was puzzling and a let down. I wonder if R* had DLC other than side mission planned to continue the story before being shut down. Personally, I think they spent more time on the graphical realism and voice acting over building a believable and exciting game. I would be interested in a LA Noire 2 since they had good foot hold on the technology. Too bad that will never come to be now.