These are posts coming from individuals that didn't have DREs with their Thompson drives. I had two launch XB that had frequent DREs throughout its 2 and 1/2 year lifespan. In fact, some games (Tenchu, Unreal 2, Steel Battalion) couldn't go 30 seconds without freezing or giving the error. Every single person I personally know with a Thompson XB has an ungodly # of DREs. My other XBs (I have 6 LANd in my shop) that aren't Thompsons have rare occasional DREs. Sure, it could be a coincidence, but with stuff like that its hard not to believe the hype (especially when you see it firsthand more than you would like to). Thats also not to say that every Thompson craps out, but perhaps there is a higher percentage of specific drives that do. Its similar to having a first year redesign of a car. It might not be as refined as maybe three-four years into the design. Bottom line is, its easy for you guys to say that theres no problem with Thompsons, but you all might change your tune if you saw otherwise first hand.
jefferyjrose stated it very accurately. Of course, one of my launch PS2s has never to this day had more than two DREs. Of course, we all know thats probably blind luck!!!