[quote name='Killer Rabbit']Well, yeah all 360s
are guaranteed to fail...probably sometime in the next 10-10,000 years.
The launch 360s are built like crap, but they're not
all going to die.[/QUOTE]
All launch 360's (and up to a certain mfgr. date, I imagine) have a design flaw that can cause them all to fail at some point...
Consider an analogous item. The Dodge pickups from 1999-2001 (I forget the range) had a plastic feed tube for the transmission fluid. Now, under non-towing circumstances, or in very cold areas (possibly)... the transmission fluid would not get hot enough to melt that plastic tube. BUT if you towed something (perfectly acceptable usage on a truck) or if you lived in a very warm climate, the fluid _COULD_ get hot enough to melt the tube and cause an engine fire.
There was a recall, and the trucks now have a metal tube to deliver fluid. It was a design decision that was wrong. Did it cause all trucks to catch fire? No. But the possibility existed for _all_ trucks to catch fire at some point. The same holds true for the 3-Red rings.
This MS extension of warranty for the 3 Red Rings is their attempt to avoid a full-scale recall, and at the same time avoid any bad PR associated with the flaw. (As much as possible, I mean.) Otherwise, they'd have extended the warranty to 3 years for _all_ the failures. Make no mistake... it was a design decision to make the heatsink like they did. Whatever the reason (cost-cutting, etc), is not the issue. If it weren't a design failure, you wouldn't see redesigned heatsinks on newly manufactured models.
I still enjoy the console, but let's all not fanboy it up and claim MS is being a benevolent giant over all this. (I'm speaking to the royal "we" here...)