They just sent me an email saying they are refunding the amount I paid for the shirt ($17.95). Oh well, I'd actually like for them to reprint it but I'm not going to argue at this point. They acknowledged that it was their mistake (they told the printer the wrong colored shirt to print on) and handled it very fast. I'd still order from them again.
So then everyone who bought that got a shirt like that then. You'd think they would put it back up for sale.