How much is this bundle worth?

Hi guys.  I have a guy on Craigslist who is interested in purchasing a large bundle of games from me.  I initially just posted about selling my sealed copy of The Last Story, and he asked if I had anything else up for sale as well.  I got back to him with a list of NES games and N64 games and he wants to know how much I will sell for as a bundle.  I almost never sell games, but I am hard for some money at the moment.

Here is what I've got:

Nintendo 64 System with hookups and one controller.

Mario Kart 64

Mario Party 2

Mario Party 3

Pokemon Stadium

Pokemon Stadium 2

NES System with 2 controllers and a Zapper


Alfred Chicken

Astyanax

Bases Loaded

Battletoads

Bionic Commando

Castlevania

Castlevania 2

Castlevania 3

Demon Sword

Donkey Kong Jr

Double Dribble

Dragon Warrior

Duck Tales

Fighting Golf

Golf

Ice Hockey

Jack Nicklaus Golf

Kung Fu

Mario/Duck Hunt

Megaman 2

Megaman 3

Metroid

Monster Party

Pac-man (Tengen)

Rad Racer

River City Ransom

Scheherazade

Sesame Street ABC

Simpson Bart vs The World

Star Wars

Super Jeopardy

Super Mario 2

Super Mario 3

Tecmo Super Bowl

Teenage Mutant Ninja Turtles

The Legend of Zelda

TMNT 2 The Arcade Game

Top Gun

I also am selling a sealed copy of The Last Story Limited Ed. and a like new copy of Atelier Totori Premium Ed.  It seems The Last Story has sold from $50 and up, and Atelier has sold at like $40 roughly on Ebay.

I was thinking of quoting him $200 for everything, but then again I don't sell frequently and never in bundles.  So Im not sure what a good bundle discount is.

Any input you guys may have would be much appreciated.

You should sell TLS LE (with CD?) for at least $60 cash to the guy.  Atelier Totori is Premium is worth more like $60-$80 I think

I really suggest you sell the N64/NES stuff online as you'd get more though will have to pay for shipping etc.

Most of my NES collection was stolen a year ago so I'd be willing to buy some of the NES stuff.  I'm sure others would too.  Consider doing a lowball auction in the trading forums.

Yeah, TLS has the cd in there too.  Atelier Totori was bought new at Gamestop, but it has the sticker on the actual front box, wasn't sealed but just with a clear sticker across the opening. 

I was trying to do a cash transaction in person because I've honestly only ever used eBay one time in my life and I got ripped off.  I don't even have a PayPal account.  Plus the sooner I get the money, the better.

Those N64 games go for at least $20 each when sold individually. With boxes, you should aim for $35 for each. Some good NES games in there too, like the Castlevanias, Marios, and Megamans, which should get you $10 or more apiece.

If you want to sell all of that as a bundle, I suggest asking for $250 and compromising to around $220. You wouldn't get as much on ebay since they take 15%, but you could get $200-250 in a CAG lowball. You just list your items and people on the forum outbid each other, then pay you the agreed amount plus shipping either with Amazon, Paypal, or concealed cash. No commitment to ship until you receive payment, so you'd be safe as a seller.

Some of those games are rare, and he'd be a fool not to take you up on it if they're in good condition/boxed.

Thanks for the input guys.  Hipster Chocobo, I took your advice and shot him a price of 250.  I'd be happy with the 220, but honestly if he offered me 200 cash today, I'd probably have to take it.  I almost never sell or trade in games, but I lost my job and am desperate for a few extra bucks before the end of the week.  I really hope to have a new job soon before I have to start parting with my SNES or PS1 collections.  I know those ones are a lot more valuable but I don't want to sell them unless it's that or get kicked out of my place.

Just for a bit of closure to the thread, I suggested $250, he said he was at $200.  We agreed to meet in the middle at $225.  Met up with him and the transaction went smoothly.  He showed me some of his pictures on his phone of his video game collection and I swear he must be a CAG lol.  He also showed me his Xbox gamerscore and he had something ridiculous like 170,000.  I'm glad the games went to a good home and not to a reseller though.