Damn I bought this for $13 last week! Its a fun game though. Dont get the hate for it. I'd say 1>3>2 from best to worst. Although I enjoyed all of them.
I remember you mentioning this a while back. Glad to hear you enjoyed it. It trades in for $14 at Best Buy this week I think, so you can at least get your money back (the PS3 version trades in for way more, which sucks.)
I tried to get this twice in the last 2 weeks at $13. The both game disc has chips and scratches on them. The second one was also dirty. I will try a 3rd time for a decent disc. At least the price dropped. My Gears Judgment disc and Hitman disc were in great shape.
Yeah I've had a moderate amount of trouble with 360 discs from Gamefly, but they have great customer service and always give fast refunds. I'd prefer to order this game for PS3, but alas it's not on sale.