I don't think I'd start with Craigslist. People will send you messages saying you're asking too much or will offer around 200, along with lying that you can easily find it in stores.
I tried selling my Pikachu 3DS a week after launch and had that happen to me.
Most people on CL are cheapasses.
Yeah; Craigslist can be a pain in the ass. It depends on how much you value your time vs money: you lose 13% on eBay, but you don't have to deal with dumbasses like Ferrari Racer mentioned.
I've made it a habit of just selling on eBay because of flaky buyers. Figure out the price you'd like to sell it for, and the minimum price you'll sell it for. List it as a Buy it Now auction and hit the option to decline offers below $X. You don't even have to look at people offering below your minimum price unless you want to.
- CAiNiAC likes this