I'd be happy with the Sam and Max seasons and StrongBad at the $1 level. It's not like Telltale sells many of those nowadays.
This. Throw all the older crap not in the last bundle (Sam Max Seasons 1 & 2, StrongBad, Telltale Poker, Bone, Tales of Monkey Island Complete) and put it in the $1-tier and I'll be more than thrilled.
And you guys must be magic or something, seeing as there's been a LotR marathon on TNT all day.
Because what better way to spend the entirety of a day than watching the entire LotR trilogy and the first Hobbit film back to back WITH COMMERCIALS.