[quote name='bigdaddybruce44']Sorry, but I'd have to respectfully disagree with you. The fight was pretty bad and did not convey the epic nature that it did in the comics. I understand what you're saying about time constrictions, but that doesn't excuse the poor quality that it, in my opinion and the opinion of many others, had. If they couldn't do it right in that amount of time, they shouldn't have done it at all. The Death and Return of Superman was a seminal moment in comic history, and they butchered it all to hell.
I will agree, though, that the extras were quite good.[/QUOTE]
The film was focused on the Death of Superman, not the Return.
While historic, the story's greatest impact was the changes with Green Lantern (and the eventual Batman: Knightfall story that ended up following it).
I grew up with the story as well, but this wasn't intended to be a direct transfer of the story (given the continuity, it couldn't be)... but an homage to the story.
People have different opinions, it happens.