[quote name='BigSpoonyBard']The problem with this strategy is that each one of those new cards pings your credit score. And the 0% only lasts a few months before the rate goes up to the same place you were at before. This is a strategy that can actually hurt your overall credit score.
If you can't get a consolidation loan, focus on paying one card down at a time. Cut out extraneous expenses for a while. Pack your lunches. Put all your extra money on the card you've chosen, while paying slightly above your minimum on the others (e.g., rounding up to the next even $10 increment). Once you've got one card paid down, go to the next. The key thing is to not let the feeling of being overwhelmed get to you. Stay calm, and act rationally.
Here's a nice little article about
some of the bad strategies, and some of the good.[/QUOTE]
Ramsey is good, but he is conservative because he knows he is speaking to a broad audience and most of them are not responsible enough to make the "challenging" plans work.
I know someone who paid off $50,000+ by juggling 0% cards, and his credit score was not hurt in the least by the little "pings". So long as you're closing the old cards, for every ding your credit score takes, there is an opposite plus for closing a different card. Additionally, every time you make an on-time payment your credit score benefits. You just have to be SURE you are responsible enough to manage the juggling act and use a little common sense in which 0% cards you accept. Some only give you 6 months, others give you 13 months.
The debt consolidation plans are a scam that play on your inner desire to fail at getting rid of your debt. They offer a lower monthly payment amount, but in the long-run you're worse off because you're paying a lot more over the years.
Other option is to borrow from someone who REALLY trusts you (parents). In that case I would be tempted to put something up as collateral. Threat of a lost car will motivate you to pay your friend or family member back, and losing the car would be better than losing a relationship. This option would be my last resort.
You could also suffer through an extra job (an excellent Ramsey recommendation).
It really comes down to: How bad do you really want out of debt? Are you annoyed by it, or are you committed to getting out?