[quote name='Sk']I'm not a GC fan boy. My xbox is my favorite console, then my game cube, and lastly my PS2. IMO my most favorite controller ever is the large XBOX controller (It feels good in my hands, but its understandable why others hate it). However as I posted a while ago, I think the NGC's controller rocks for RPGS and now that people mention it Platform games. It does suck for fighters.[/QUOTE]
It sucks for fighters, with the two exceptions of SSBM and SC2.
The controller s is good for two things and two things only: racing and FPS.
The DS2 is a decent controller if you don't care about analog control. It's only really suited to THPS and fighting games.